The Harms of Screening
- 1 February 2014
- journal article
- review article
- Published by American Medical Association (AMA) in JAMA Internal Medicine
- Vol. 174 (2), 281-286
- https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2013.12745
Abstract
Importance Making rational decisions about screening requires information about its harms, but high-quality evidence is often either not available or not used. One reason may be that we lack a coherent framework, a taxonomy, for conceptualizing and studying these harms. Objective To create a taxonomy, we categorized harms from several sources: systematic reviews of screening, other published literature, and informal discussions with clinicians and patients. We used this information to develop an initial taxonomy and vetted it with local and national experts, making revisions as needed. Results We propose a taxonomy with 4 domains of harm from screening: physical effects, psychological effects, financial strain, and opportunity costs. Harms can occur at any step of the screening cascade. We provide definitions for each harm domain and illustrate the taxonomy using the example of screening for lung cancer. Conclusions and Relevance The taxonomy provides a systematic way to conceptualize harms as experienced by patients. As shown in the lung cancer screening example, the taxonomy also makes clear where (which domains of harms and which parts of the screening cascade) we have useful information and where there are gaps in our knowledge. The taxonomy needs further testing and validation across a broad range of screening programs. We hope that further development of this taxonomy can improve our thinking about the harms of screening, thus informing our research, policy making, and decision making with patients about the wisdom of screening.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Psychosocial consequences of allocation to lung cancer screening: a randomised controlled trialBMJ Open, 2012
- Reduced Lung-Cancer Mortality with Low-Dose Computed Tomographic ScreeningThe New England Journal of Medicine, 2011
- Population-Based Risk for Complications After Transthoracic Needle Lung Biopsy of a Pulmonary Nodule: An Analysis of Discharge RecordsAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2011
- Reconsidering the Criteria for Evaluating Proposed Screening Programs: Reflections From 4 Current and Former Members of the U.S. Preventive Services Task ForceEpidemiologic Reviews, 2011
- Decision-Making Processes for Breast, Colorectal, and Prostate Cancer Screening: The DECISIONS SurveyMedical Decision Making, 2010
- Consequences of Screening in Lung Cancer: Development and Dimensionality of a QuestionnaireValue in Health, 2010
- Update on the Methods of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force: Estimating Certainty and Magnitude of Net BenefitAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2007
- Challenges in Systematic Reviews That Assess Treatment HarmsAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2005
- Enthusiasm for Cancer Screening in the United StatesJAMA, 2004
- Lung Cancer Mortality in the Mayo Lung Project: Impact of Extended Follow-upJNCI Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2000