Telling Policy Stories: An Ethnographic Study of the Use of Evidence in Policy-making in the UK
- 10 November 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Social Policy
- Vol. 40 (2), 237-255
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0047279410000723
Abstract
Based on participant observation in a team of British policy-making civil servants carried out in 2009, this article examines the use that is made of evidence in making policy. It shows that these civil servants displayed a high level of commitment to the use of evidence. However, their use of evidence was hampered by the huge volume of various kinds of evidence and by the unsuitability of much academic research in answering policy questions. Faced with this deluge of inconclusive information, they used evidence to create persuasive policy stories. These stories were useful both in making acceptable policies and in advancing careers. They often involved the excision of methodological uncertainty and the use of ‘killer charts’ to boost the persuasiveness of the narrative. In telling these stories, social inequality was ‘silently silenced’ in favour of promoting policies which were ‘totemically’ tough. The article concludes that this selective, narrative use of evidence is ideological in that it supports systematically asymmetrical relations of power.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Complexity of Evidence: Reflections on Research Utilisation in a Heavily Politicised Policy AreaSocial Policy and Society, 2009
- Health inequalities in Scotland and England: the contrasting journeys of ideas from research into policySocial Science & Medicine (1982), 2007
- When two dark figures collide: Evidence and discourse on drug-related crimeCritical Social Policy, 2007
- The social exclusion discourse: ideas and policy changePolicy & Politics, 2007
- Survival of the Ideas that Fit: An Evolutionary Analogy for the Use of Evidence in PolicySocial Policy and Society, 2007
- ‘Evidence-based policy’ and the government of the criminal justice system - only if the evidence fits!Critical Social Policy, 2005
- The Perilous Road from Evidence to Policy: Five Journeys ComparedJournal of Social Policy, 2005
- Evidence-Based Policy or Policy-Based Evidence? Hutton and the Government's Use of Secret IntelligenceParliamentary Affairs, 2005
- The Institutional Arrangements for Connecting Evidence and Policy: the Case of Drug MisusePublic Policy and Administration, 2002
- Research and policy: What determines the relationship?Policy Studies, 1996