The dappled nature of causes of psychiatric illness: replacing the organic–functional/hardware–software dichotomy with empirically based pluralism
Top Cited Papers
- 10 January 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Molecular Psychiatry
- Vol. 17 (4), 377-388
- https://doi.org/10.1038/mp.2011.182
Abstract
Our tendency to see the world of psychiatric illness in dichotomous and opposing terms has three major sources: the philosophy of Descartes, the state of neuropathology in late nineteenth century Europe (when disorders were divided into those with and without demonstrable pathology and labeled, respectively, organic and functional), and the influential concept of computer functionalism wherein the computer is viewed as a model for the human mind–brain system (brain=hardware, mind=software). These mutually re-enforcing dichotomies, which have had a pernicious influence on our field, make a clear prediction about how ‘difference-makers’ (aka causal risk factors) for psychiatric disorders should be distributed in nature. In particular, are psychiatric disorders like our laptops, which when they dysfunction, can be cleanly divided into those with software versus hardware problems? I propose 11 categories of difference-makers for psychiatric illness from molecular genetics through culture and review their distribution in schizophrenia, major depression and alcohol dependence. In no case do these distributions resemble that predicted by the organic–functional/hardware–software dichotomy. Instead, the causes of psychiatric illness are dappled, distributed widely across multiple categories. We should abandon Cartesian and computer-functionalism-based dichotomies as scientifically inadequate and an impediment to our ability to integrate the diverse information about psychiatric illness our research has produced. Empirically based pluralism provides a rigorous but dappled view of the etiology of psychiatric illness. Critically, it is based not on how we wish the world to be but how the difference-makers for psychiatric illness are in fact distributed.Keywords
This publication has 122 references indexed in Scilit:
- Immune suppression and immune activation in depressionBrain, Behavior, and Immunity, 2011
- The environment and susceptibility to schizophreniaProgress in Neurobiology, 2011
- Genome-wide association study of major depressive disorder: new results, meta-analysis, and lessons learnedMolecular Psychiatry, 2010
- The Genetics of Major Depression: Moving Beyond the Monoamine HypothesisPsychiatric Clinics of North America, 2010
- Explicit and implicit measures of expectancy and related alcohol cognitions: A meta-analytic comparison.Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 2010
- The CRF system, stress, depression and anxiety—insights from human genetic studiesMolecular Psychiatry, 2009
- Poverty, life events and the risk for depression in UgandaSocial psychiatry. Sozialpsychiatrie. Psychiatrie sociale, 2009
- Should the diagnosis of major depression be made independent of or dependent upon the psychosocial context?Psychological Medicine, 2009
- The role of GABAA receptors in the development of alcoholismPharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior, 2008
- Genetic and Environmental Influences on Alcohol, Caffeine, Cannabis, and Nicotine Use From Early Adolescence to Middle AdulthoodArchives of General Psychiatry, 2008