Tobacco industry argues domestic trademark laws and international treaties preclude cigarette health warning labels, despite consistent legal advice that the argument is invalid: Table 1
- 24 November 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
- Vol. 23 (3), e7
- https://doi.org/10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2012-050569
Abstract
Objectives To analyse the tobacco industry's use of international trade agreements to oppose policies to strengthen health warning labels (HWLs). Design A review of tobacco industry documents, tobacco control legislation and international treaties. Results During the early 1990s, the tobacco industry became increasingly alarmed about the advancement of HWLs on cigarettes packages. In response, it requested legal opinions from British American Tobacco's law firms in Australia and England, Britain's Department of Trade and Industry and the World Intellectual Property Organisation on the legality of restricting and prohibiting the use of their trademarks, as embodied in cigarette packages. The consistent legal advice, privately submitted to the companies, was that international treaties do not shield trademark owners from government limitations (including prohibition) on the use of their trademarks. Despite receiving this legal advice, the companies publicly argued that requiring large HWLs compromised their trademark rights under international treaties. The companies successfully used these arguments as part of their successful effort to deter Canadian and Australian governments from enacting laws requiring the plan packaging of cigarettes, which helped delay large graphic HWLs, including ‘plain’ packaging, for over a decade. Conclusions Governments should not be intimidated by tobacco company threats and unsubstantiated claims, and carefully craft HWL laws to withstand the inevitable tobacco industry lawsuits with the knowledge that the companies’ own lawyers as well as authoritative bodies have told the companies that the rights they claim do not exist.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- International trade versus public health during the FCTC negotiations, 1999-2003Tobacco Control, 2010
- “Working the System”—British American Tobacco's Influence on the European Union Treaty and Its Implications for Policy: An Analysis of Internal Tobacco Industry DocumentsPLoS Medicine, 2010
- Estimating the impacts of cigarette taxes on youth smoking participation, initiation, and persistence: empirical evidence from CanadaHealth Economics, 2009
- The tobacco industry's thwarting of marketing restrictions and health warnings in LebanonTobacco Control, 2009
- The strategic targeting of females by transnational tobacco companies in South Korea following trade liberalisationGlobalization and Health, 2009
- Global influences on milk purchasing in New Zealand – implications for health and inequalitiesGlobalization and Health, 2009
- Signed, sealed and delivered: “big tobacco” in Hollywood, 1927–1951Tobacco Control, 2008
- Tobacco industry issues management organizations: Creating a global corporate network to undermine public healthGlobalization and Health, 2008
- Can a bank crisis break your heart?Globalization and Health, 2008
- Political economy of tobacco control in ThailandTobacco Control, 2001