Growth and carcass characteristics of crossbred lambs by ten sire breeds, compared at the same estimated carcass subcutaneous fat proportion

Abstract

An evaluation was carried out over a 5-year period in 10 commercial flocks of Scottish Blackface, Scottish Half-bred and Mule ewes to evaluate 10 sire breeds: Border Leicester, Dorset Down, Hampshire Down, He de France, North Country Cheviot, Oxford Down, Southdown, Suffolk, Texel and Wensleydale. An average of 43 sires was used per sire breed.The analysis involved a total of 3360 lambs of which one-third had the left side dissected. Sire breeds were compared when their progeny were slaughtered at the same estimated carcass subcutaneous fat proportion (approx. 120 g/kg).Carcass weights were related to the adult body size of the sire breeds with a range of 4 kg between Southdown and Wensleydale crosses. Crosses by the conventional meat sire breeds tended to have higher daily carcass-weight and lean-tissue gains than those by Border Leicester and Wensleydale sires. Texel and Suffolk crosses did not differ significantly in carcass weight, daily carcass-weight gain, daily lean gain or age at slaughter (P > 0·05).Significant sire-breed × dam-breed interactions were recorded for daily carcass-weight gain and daily lean gain (P < 0·05). Dorset Down and Southdown crosses tended to grow relatively faster when from Mule dams; Texel crosses grew relatively faster when from Blackface dams.There was relatively little difference between sire breeds in visually assessed carcass conformation; all the means were within two points on a 15-point scale. Texel crosses had a higher carcass lean proportion than other crosses: their advantage over Suffolk crosses was 22 g/kg.