Visibility of microcalcification clusters and masses in breast tomosynthesis image volumes and digital mammography: A 4AFC human observer study

Abstract

Purpose : To investigate the visibility of simulated lesions in digital breast tomosynthesis (BT) image volumes compared with 2D digital mammography (DM). Methods : Simulated lesions (masses and microcalcifications) were added to images of the same women acquired on a DM system (Mammomat Novation, Siemens) and a BT prototype. The same beam quality was used for the DM and BT acquisitions. The total absorbed dose resulting from a 25‐projection BT acquisition and reconstruction (BT₂₅) was approximately twice that of a single DM view. By excluding every other projection image from the reconstruction (BT₁₃), approximately the same dose as in DM was effected. Simulated microcalcifications were digitally added with varying contrast to the DM and BT images. Simulated masses with 8 mm diameter were also added to BT images. A series of 4‐alternative forced choice (4AFC) human observer experiments were conducted. Four medical physicists participated in all experiments, each consisting of 60 trials per experimental condition. The observers interpreted the BT image volumes in cine‐mode at a fixed image sequence speed. The required threshold contrast (S_t) to achieve a detectability index (d′) of 2.5 (i.e., 92.5% correct decisions) was determined. Results : The S_t for mass detection in DM was approximately a factor of 2 higher than required in BT indicating that the detection of masses was improved under BT conditions compared to DM. S_t for microcalcification detection was higher for BT than for DM at both BT dose levels (BT₂₅ and BT₁₃), with a statistically significant difference in S_t between DM and BT₁₃. These results indicate a dose‐dependent decrease in detection performance in BT for detection of microcalcifications. Conclusions : In agreement with previous investigations, masses of size 8 mm can be detected with less contrast in BT than in DM indicating improved detection performance for BT. However, for the investigated microcalcifications, the results of this study indicate potentially worse performance for BT than for DM at the same dose level.