Reprise fragments in English and Hungarian: Further support for an in-situ Q-equivalence approach to clausal ellipsis
- 1 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in Language
- Vol. 99 (1), 154-191
- https://doi.org/10.1353/lan.2023.0000
Abstract
We present a comparative analysis of English and Hungarian reprise fragments. We argue that reprise fragments should be afforded the same theoretical treatment as standard (i.e. nonreprise) fragments. Assuming that standard fragmentary answers and questions are remnants of an ellipsis operation that applies to a clause, this entails that reprise fragments are also remnants of clausal ellipsis. We show that the prevailing approach to standard fragments, which assumes that the remnant of ellipsis always undergoes movement (Merchant 2001, 2004), cannot be plausibly extended to explain the crosslinguistic reprise-fragment data. We argue that a theory is required that restricts antecedents to interrogatives and that allows—but crucially does not require—movement of the remnant. Under this account, the differences observed between English and Hungarian reprise and standard fragments follow from independent syntactic differences in how standard and reprise questions are formed in these languages. We therefore provide new evidence to support theories of ellipsis identity that state that only questions make for suitable antecedents for clausal ellipsis (so-called Q-equivalence approaches) and to support sententialist analyses of clausal ellipsis that permit ellipsis to occur around designated constituents (so-called in-situ approaches).Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Syntactic identity, Parallelism and accommodated antecedentsLingua, 2015
- Parasitic Gaps licensed by elided syntactic structureNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2014
- Contrast and Island Sensitivity in Clausal EllipsisSyntax, 2014
- Sluicing, Idioms, and Island RepairLinguistic Inquiry, 2013
- Information structure in discourse: Towards an integrated formal theory of pragmaticsSemantics and Pragmatics, 2012
- Left-edge deletion in English and subject omission in diariesEnglish Language and Linguistics, 2012
- P-stranding under sluicing and repair by ellipsis: why is Indonesian (not) special?Journal of East Asian Linguistics, 2011
- Silent interactions: Spanish TP-ellipsis and the theory of island repairProbus, 2010
- Clarification, Ellipsis, and the Nature of Contextual Updates in DialogueLinguistics and Philosophy, 2004
- Question/Answer Congruence and the Semantics of wh-phrasesTheoretical Linguistics, 2002