Reframing the evaluation of qualitative health research: reflections on a review of appraisal guidelines in the health sciences
- 1 May 2003
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
- Vol. 9 (2), 187-194
- https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2753.2003.00392.x
Abstract
In this article, we explore the form of evaluation put forward by guidelines used in the health sciences for appraising qualitative research and we begin to articulate an alternative posture. Most guidelines are derivative of the modes of assessment developed by clinical epidemiologists as part of the promotion of evidence‐based medicine (EBM). They are predominantly proceduralist in orientation, equating quality with the proper execution of research techniques. We argue that this form of judgment assumes a fixed relationship between research practice and knowledge generated, and tends to over‐simplify and standardize the complex and non‐formulaic nature of qualitative inquiry. A concern with methods as objects of judgment in and of themselves restricts the reader's field of vision to the research process and diverts attention away from the analytic content of the research. We propose an alternative ‘substantive’ perspective that focuses on the analysis put forward, and regards methods as resources for engaging with and understanding the substantive findings and topic of inquiry. An important challenge is to find a way to embody such a form of judgment in practical assessment tools.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Myth 94: Qualitative Health Researchers will Agree about ValidityQualitative Health Research, 2001
- Checklists for improving rigour in qualitative research: a case of the tail wagging the dog?BMJ, 2001
- Arguments for ‘British Pluralism’ in qualitative health researchJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2001
- Qualitative research in health care: Assessing quality in qualitative researchBMJ, 2000
- The good, the bad and the relative, part two: Goodness and the criterion problem in qualitative researchInternational Journal of Nursing Practice, 1999
- Qualitative Research and the Gingerbread ManHealth Education Journal, 1995
- Qualitative Research: Reaching the parts other methods cannot reach: an introduction to qualitative methods in health and health services researchBMJ, 1995
- Qualitative research methods in general practice and primary careFamily Practice, 1995
- Why we need qualitative research.Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 1994
- A Systematic Approach for Using Qualitative Methods in Primary Prevention ResearchMedical Anthropology Quarterly, 1990