How Well Can Physicians Estimate Mortality in a Medical Intensive Care Unit?
- 1 June 1989
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 9 (2), 125-132
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989x8900900207
Abstract
The accuracies of physicians' predictions of mortality for 523 patients in a medical intensive care unit were compared with estimates derived from a logistic model. The model utilized a popular severity-of-illness measure, the APACHE II. Accuracy was assessed through its components resolution (discrimination) and calibration. Physicians could better discriminate survivors from nonsurvivors, as measured by the area under the receiver operating char acteristic curve (0.89 for physicians vs 0.83 for APACHE II model, p <0.001) and by resolution (0.103 for physicians vs 0.130 for APACHE II model, p <0.001). Overall, the APACHE 11 model was better calibrated (0.003 for APACHE II vs 0.021 for physicians, p <0.001). While the APACHE II model was better calibrated in the central probability ranges, physicians could more accurately identify those most likely to die. Decisions on withholding or with drawing treatment are being made daily in intensive care units based on physicians' sub jective prognostic estimates. At least for experienced physicians at a major medical center, these estimates are comparable in accuracy to quantitative models. Key words: intensive care unit; prognosis; severity of illness; quantitative models; decision making. (Med Decis Making 1989;9:125-132)Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Resuscitation: How Do We Decide?Published by American Medical Association (AMA) ,1986
- APACHE IICritical Care Medicine, 1985
- A method for predicting survival and mortality of ICU patients using objectively derived weightsCritical Care Medicine, 1985
- Variability in Physician Bioethical Decision-MakingAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1982
- Prognosis, Survival, and the Expenditure of Hospital Resources for Patients in an Intensive-Care UnitNew England Journal of Medicine, 1981
- APACHE—acute physiology and chronic health evaluation: a physiologically based classification systemCritical Care Medicine, 1981
- Prognosis in Nontraumatic ComaAnnals of Internal Medicine, 1981
- Intensive-Care Units: Who Needs Them?New England Journal of Medicine, 1980
- ORGANIZATION AND OUTCOME OF CRITICAL CARECritical Care Medicine, 1978
- Prediction of survival in intensive care patientsCritical Care Medicine, 1976