WRITING AMISH CULTURE INTO GENES: BIOLOGICAL REDUCTIONISM IN A STUDY OF MANIC DEPRESSION
- 1 January 1997
- journal article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry
- Vol. 21 (2), 137-159
- https://doi.org/10.1023/a:1005352727300
Abstract
Critical realism is used to explore the problem of reductionism in a classic (the Amish Study) andwidely-cited study of manic depression. Along withrelated ideas drawn from the works of R.C.Lewontin, Arthur Kleinman, and Byron Good, it isshown that natural and social scientists deployatomistic and holistic reductionism; this, in turn,leads to the construction of artificially ’closedsystems' through the control of variables orexogenous forces. The psychiatric genetic studies ofthe Amish were predicated on the assumption thatAmish society is homogeneous and unchanging and,therefore, closed. We conclude by arguing thatinteractions between behaviors and genes, where theyexist, take place only within open systems, characterizedby multiple mechanisms – social andbiological – that together co-determineany event. To move forward, it is argued, behavior and generesearch requires recognition and resolution of thephilosophical conundrums that accompany reductionism.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- A linkage study of distal chromosome 5q and bipolar disorderBiological Psychiatry, 1994
- Update on the search for DNA markers linked to manic-depressive illness in the old order amishJournal of Psychiatric Research, 1992
- Molecular-Biologic Basis of Manic-Depressive IllnessPharmacopsychiatry, 1992
- Linkage of bipolar affective disorders to markers on chromosome 11p is excluded in a second lateral extension of Amish Pedigree 110Genomics, 1991
- Manic Depression Gene Put in LimboScience, 1989
- Re-evaluation of the linkage relationship between chromosome 11p loci and the gene for bipolar affective disorder in the Old Order AmishNature, 1989
- False start on manic depressionNature, 1989
- Reliability and relationship of various ages of onset criteria for major affective disorderJournal of Affective Disorders, 1987
- Bipolar affective disorders linked to DNA markers on chromosome 11Nature, 1987
- Manic-Depression: Is It Inherited?Science, 1986