Dichotomies, dialectics and dilemmas: New directions for critical leadership studies?
- 7 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Leadership
- Vol. 10 (1), 36-55
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1742715013510807
Abstract
This article builds on Fairhurst and Connaughton’s proposals for future research agendas in leadership studies by critically examining three key themes in the leadership literature: dichotomies, dialectics, and dilemmas. The first section argues that mainstream leadership research frequently relies on conceptual dichotomies which are often multiple, inter-related, and proliferating. Critiques of dichotomization are suggestive of more dialectical forms of analysis and these are discussed in the second section. Dialectical studies can surface important questions about organizational power relations, paradoxes and contradictions that are typically under-explored within mainstream leadership studies. The third section proposes an additional, future research theme for critical perspectives, namely whether and if so why, how, and with what consequences leaders may engage in discourses of denial regarding the dilemmas and tensions of organizational life. The article concludes by arguing that re-framing leadership dichotomies as multiple, intersecting dialectics can open up fresh lines of enquiry and generate important insights about the complex and situated relations of power and identity that comprise leadership and followership dynamics.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- Treading Fine LinesJournal of Management Inquiry, 2013
- Prozac leadership and the limits of positive thinkingLeadership, 2012
- Situating Organizations in PoliticsManagement Communication Quarterly, 2009
- Managing Dualities in Planned Change InitiativesJournal of Applied Communication Research, 2008
- Sensemaking and the Distortion of Critical Upward Communication in OrganizationsJournal of Management Studies, 2006
- LeadershipLeadership, 2005
- Dialectic, contradiction, or double bind? Analyzing and theorizing employee reactions to organizational tensionJournal of Applied Communication Research, 2004
- Dialectical Tensions and Rhetorical Tropes in NegotiationsOrganization Studies, 2004
- Isn't it ironic: Using irony to explore the contradictions of organizational lifeWestern Journal of Communication, 1999
- Organization Theory in the Age of Deconstruction: Dualism, Gender and Postmodernism RevisitedOrganization Studies, 1997