Evaluating Devolution in Wales
- 1 March 2003
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Political Studies
- Vol. 51 (1), 51-66
- https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9248.00412
Abstract
Reviews of devolution in Wales have been focussed so far on empirical description and positive analysis; there has been almost no discussion of how it should be judged or evaluated. I redress this imbalance by considering the arguments for devolution and the various normative values that may be used to evaluate the process. The arguments for devolution are of two basic kinds. Some are consequentialist: that devolution is desired on the grounds that it is believed to have good or desirable effects. Others are deontological: that devolution is thought to be intrinsically valuable. Any attempt to justify and evaluate devolution by consequentialist reasoning amounts to post hoc ergo propter hoc rationalisation. The social sciences are a long way from allowing the prediction of the global long-term net equilibrium effects of a major institutional change such as devolution in Wales. I further argue that the nonconsequentialist value of autonomy is the underlying justification for the devolution process. Devolution should be judged according to how it appeals to, supports or embodies this value.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Settlement and Process of Devolution: Territorial Politics and Governance under the Welsh AssemblyPolitical Studies, 2001
- Constitutional design: a framework for analysisParliamentary Affairs, 2000
- Devolution and the New Context for Public Policy-making: Lessons from the EU Structural Funds in WalesPublic Policy and Administration, 2000
- Intergovernmental Relations after Devolution: The National Assembly for WalesThe Political Quarterly, 2000
- Changing the Landscape? The Wider Political Lessons from Recent Elections in WalesThe Political Quarterly, 2000
- Policy Legitimacy and Institutional Design: Comparative Lessons for theEuropean UnionJCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2000
- The Welsh Office and Welsh AutonomyPublic Administration, 1999
- Democratic accountability and central bank independence: Historical and contemporary, national and European perspectivesWest European Politics, 1998
- Elections, parties and institutional design: A comparative perspective on European Union democracyWest European Politics, 1998
- The devolution debate in Wales during the major governments: The politics of a developing union state?Regional & Federal Studies, 1998