Exploring the Function of Criminal Law in the Policing of Foreigners
- 10 September 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social & Legal Studies
- Vol. 21 (4), 511-527
- https://doi.org/10.1177/0964663912455447
Abstract
This paper looks at the decision-making process in cases involving immigration-related crimes. Based on interviews with practitioners and immigration staff and the analysis of court-files, it disentangles the criteria guiding both enforcement officers and prosecutors in the decision to criminally proceed against suspected immigration offenders. The reasons behind the policy and practice of prosecuting immigration crimes show that criminal law is but one means to enforce immigration rules. The role that criminal law is called to play in this context is purely instrumental as the main consideration for pursuing a case is the impact that it may have on immigration enforcement. Criminal law is emptied of any condemnatory function and, as such, its primary function of censuring wrongs is disrupted. The examination of the decision-making process in these cases reveals how problematic it is to reconcile retribution and punishment with immigration imperatives.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Regulatory and Legal Aspects of PenalityPublished by Stanford University Press ,2011
- Deportation, detention and foreign-national prisoners in England and WalesCitizenship Studies, 2011
- THE INVESTIGATION AND PROSECUTION OF REGULATORY OFFENCES: IS THERE AN ECONOMIC CASE FOR INTEGRATION?The Cambridge Law Journal, 2011
- Immigration control, post-Fordism, and less eligibilityPunishment & Society, 2010
- Methodological Approaches for Interviewing ElitesGeography Compass, 2010
- Migration, Crime and VictimhoodPunishment & Society, 2003
- No Borders: The Case against Immigration ControlsFeminist Review, 2003
- Who Should Get in? The Ethics of Immigration AdmissionsEthics & International Affairs, 2003
- Breaking the Convention: Researching the “Illegal” Migration of Refugees to EuropeAntipode, 2003
- WHITE-COLLAR CRIME AND THE ENFORCEMENT OF FACTORY LEGISLATIONThe British Journal of Criminology, 1970