The impact of interventionist regulation in reshaping news agendas: A comparative analysis of public and commercially funded television journalism
- 24 January 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 13 (7), 831-849
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1464884911431536
Abstract
In this article we draw on a specific case study – the re-regulation of BBC political reporting in the nations and regions in the UK post-devolution – to compare the BBC’s interventionist, public service framework with the ‘light touch’ regime of commercial broadcasting. We carried out a content analysis of BBC Television News (where issues of accuracy and impartiality are regulated by the BBC Trust), and three commercially funded channels (where programme content is entirely regulated by Ofcom) before and after an editorial intervention by the BBC Trust.We found that the BBC improved the balance and accuracy of its television news coverage whereas commercial broadcasters continued to overlook or misrepresent the reality of devolved politics in the UK. While it can be difficult to demonstrate empirically how regulation can enhance media content compared to a ‘light touch’ system – as our study found – we suggest that the impact of regulatory interventions should be more central to journalism studies internationally.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Crime, foreigners and hard news: A cross-national comparison of reporting and public perceptionJournalism, 2010
- BBC News in the United States: a `super-alternative' news medium emergesMedia, Culture & Society, 2009
- Media System, Public Knowledge and DemocracyEuropean Journal of Communication, 2009
- National Media Regulation in the Era of Free TradeEuropean Journal of Communication, 2008
- Reinventing public service broadcasting in Europe: prospects, promises and problemsMedia, Culture & Society, 2008
- Citizens and consumers: discursive debates during and after the Communications Act 2003Media, Culture & Society, 2007
- Ofcom's first year and neoliberalism's blind spot: attacking the culture of productionScreen, 2006
- Television in a digital age: what role for public service broadcasting?Economic Policy, 2005
- Supranational RegulationEuropean Journal of Communication, 2004
- "Democracy as Defeat"Television & New Media, 2003