The relationship between baseline value and its change: problems in categorization and the proposal of a new method
- 27 July 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Oral Sciences
- Vol. 113 (4), 279-288
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0722.2005.00229.x
Abstract
Oral health researchers have shown great interest in the relationship between the initial status of diseases and subsequent changes following treatment. Two main approaches have been adopted to provide evidence of a positive association between baseline values and their changes following treatment. One approach is to use correlation or regression to test the relationship between baseline measurements and subsequent change (correlation/regression approach). The second approach is to categorize the lesions into subgroups, according to threshold values, and subsequently compare the treatment effects across the two (or more) subgroups (categorization approach). However, the correlation/regression approach suffers a methodological weakness known as mathematical coupling. Consequently, the statistical procedure of testing the null hypothesis becomes inappropriate. Categorization seems to avoid the problem of mathematical coupling, although it still suffers regression to the mean. We show, first, how the appropriate null hypothesis may be established to analyze the relationship between baseline values and change in the correlation approach and, second, we use computer simulations to investigate the impact of regression to the mean on the significance testing of the differences in the average treatment effects (or average baseline values) in the categorization approach. Data available from previous literature are reanalyzed by testing the appropriate null hypotheses and the results are compared to those from testing the usual (incorrect) null hypothesis. The results indicate that both the correlation and categorization approaches can give rise to misleading conclusions and that more appropriate methods, such as Oldham's method and our new approach of deriving the correct null hypothesis, should be adopted.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clinical Evaluation of a Composite Bone Graft With a Calcium Sulfate BarrierThe Journal of Periodontology, 2004
- Clinical and radiographic findings following application of enamel matrix derivative in the treatment of intrabony defectsJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2000
- Comparison of treatments of infrabony defects with enamel matrix derivative, guided tissue regeneration with a nonresorbable membrane and Widman modified flapJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2000
- Treatment of interproximal angular defects by guided tissue regeneration: 1 year follow-upJournal of Oral Rehabilitation, 1996
- Clinical trial of cross‐linked human type I collagen as a barrier material in surgical periodontal treatmentJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1995
- Clinical effects of root debridement in molar and non‐molar teeth A 2‐year follow‐upJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1989
- Evaluation of Four Modalities of Periodontal TherapyThe Journal of Periodontology, 1988
- On the bias caused by regression toward the mean in studying the relation between change and initial valueJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1987
- Long‐term effect of surgical/non‐surgical treatment of periodontal diseaseJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 1984
- A Note on the Correlation of Parts with WholesThe American Statistician, 1968