Prohibiting public drinking in urban public spaces: A review of the evidence
- 19 December 2011
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy
- Vol. 19 (2), 91-101
- https://doi.org/10.3109/09687637.2011.640719
Abstract
Aims: The purpose of this article is to review community-based evaluations of street drinking bans, with a view to understanding the effectiveness of these laws in reducing alcohol-related harm and benefiting the community. Methods: Sixteen evaluations across 13 locations (in the UK, New Zealand and Australia) were identified. Nine themes were drawn out of the content and thematic analysis. Findings: Street drinking bans often: (1) negatively impact marginalized groups; (2) result in displacement; (3) improve perceptions of safety; (4) are enforced inconsistently; (5) improve perceptions of environment/amenity; and (6) are supported by police, traders and older people. It is unclear whether street drinking bans: (7) reduce public drinking; (8) reduce alcohol-related crime or harm; and (9) are understood and adhered to. Conclusions: There is no evidence that street drinking bans reduce alcohol-related harm or benefit the community in the other ways (aside from perceptions of safety and improvement to amenity). However, the methodological limitations of the evaluations reviewed make it difficult to draw conclusions about the effectiveness or otherwise of street drinking bans. More rigorous evaluations of the effectiveness and impacts of street drinking laws need to be undertaken given their continued proliferation across Australia and other Western countries.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Surveying the range and magnitude of alcohol's harm to others in AustraliaAddiction, 2011
- On‐ and off‐premise drinking choices among Indigenous Australians: The influence of socio‐spatial factorsDrug and Alcohol Review, 2010
- The long reaction against the wowser: The prehistory of alcohol deregulation in AustraliaHealth Sociology Review, 2010
- Fluid Boundaries—British Binge Drinking and European Civility: Alcohol and the Production and Consumption of Public SpaceSpace and Polity, 2008
- Locating Impropriety: Street Drinking, Moral Order, and the Ideological Dilemma of Public SpacePolitical Psychology, 2006
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- Beer Taxation and Alcohol-Related Traffic FatalitiesSouthern Economic Journal, 1999
- Alcohol controls and Aboriginal society: The effects of the Northern Territory restricted areas legislationAustralian Drug and Alcohol Review, 1989
- The dialectic of drinking in Australian life: from the Rum Corps to the wine columnAustralian Drug and Alcohol Review, 1988
- Comment on "The Uniform Alcoholism and Intoxication Treatment Act".Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1976