Alfred Marshall versus the historical school?
- 1 August 2005
- journal article
- e conceptual-paper
- Published by Emerald in Journal of Economic Studies
- Vol. 32 (4), 331-348
- https://doi.org/10.1108/01443580510618563
Abstract
Purpose: This paper aims to counter the view that Marshall was an opponent of the historical school. This false account has survived and prospered because it has fitted into more general conceptions of intellectual history, held by both orthodox and heterodox economists.Design/methodology/approach: Marshall's affinity with the historical school is established by examining his writings and his relationship with historical school sympathisers in the UK.Findings: It is established that Marshall regarded his work as building on historical school insights, and he repeatedly referred positively to the ideas of the German historical school. It is argued in this paper that Marshall's opposition to the historical school was confined to its anti‐theoretical wing, principally Cunningham. In other important respects Marshall's position was compatible with German and British historicism.Originality/value: In preceding literature, Marshall's affinities with the historical school have been denied, unacknowledged, or unexplored.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ultra-deductivism from Nassau Senior to Lionel Robbins and Daniel HausmanJournal of Economic Methodology, 1998
- The Appointment of Pigou as Marshall's SuccessorThe Journal of Law and Economics, 1972
- The Interdependence of Different Sources of Demand and Supply in a MarketThe Economic Journal, 1913
- The Present Position of Political EconomyThe Economic Journal, 1907
- Economics at Berlin and ViennaJournal of Political Economy, 1893
- [The Perversion of Economic History]: A ReplyThe Economic Journal, 1892
- The Perversion of Economic HistoryThe Economic Journal, 1892
- The Relativity of Economic DoctrineThe Economic Journal, 1892
- The Rehabilitation of RicardoThe Economic Journal, 1891
- The British Economic AssociationThe Economic Journal, 1891