Why Physicians Ought to Lie for Their Patients
- 14 March 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 12 (3), 4-12
- https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2011.652797
Abstract
Sometimes physicians lie to third-party payers in order to grant their patients treatment they would otherwise not receive. This strategy, commonly known as gaming the system, is generally condemned for three reasons. First, it may hurt the patient for the sake of whom gaming was intended. Second, it may hurt other patients. Third, it offends contractual and distributive justice. Hence, gaming is considered to be immoral behavior. This article is an attempt to show that, on the contrary, gaming may sometimes be a physician's duty. Under specific circumstances, gaming may be necessary from the viewpoint of the internal morality of medicine. Moreover, the objections against gaming are examples of what we call the idealistic fallacy, that is, the fallacy of passing judgments in a nonideal world according to ideal standards. Hence, the objections are inconclusive. Gaming is sometimes justified, and may even be required in the name of beneficence.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trustworthiness in Conflict of InterestAmerican Journal of Bioethics, 2011
- VULNERABILITY IN RESEARCH AND HEALTH CARE; DESCRIBING THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM?Bioethics, 2008
- A Framework for Rationing by Clinical JudgmentKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2007
- Reasonable Partiality in Professional Ethics: The Moral Division of LabourEthical Theory and Moral Practice, 2005
- Physicians' Interactions With Third-Party PayersArchives of Internal Medicine, 2004
- A Method in Search of a Purpose: The Internal Morality of MedicineJournal of Medicine and Philosophy, 2001
- Professional Autonomy and the Normative Structure of Medical PracticeTheoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 2000
- Lying for PatientsArchives of Internal Medicine, 1999
- The Internal Morality of Medicine: Explication and Application to Managed CareJournal of Medicine and Philosophy, 1998
- A Meta-Ethics for Professional MoralityEthics, 1978