The Effectiveness of Online and Blended Learning: A Meta-Analysis of the Empirical Literature
Top Cited Papers
- 1 March 2013
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Teachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education
- Vol. 115 (3), 1-47
- https://doi.org/10.1177/016146811311500307
Abstract
Background/Context: Earlier research on various forms of distance learning concluded that these technologies do not differ significantly from regular classroom instruction in terms of learning outcomes. Now that web-based learning has emerged as a major trend in both K–12 and higher education, the relative efficacy of online and face-to-face instruction needs to be revisited. The increased capabilities of web-based applications and collaboration technologies and the rise of blended learning models combining web-based and face-to-face classroom instruction have raised expectations for the effectiveness of online learning. Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study: This meta-analysis was designed to produce a statistical synthesis of studies contrasting learning outcomes for either fully online or blended learning conditions with those of face-to-face classroom instruction. Population/Participants/Subjects: The types of learners in the meta-analysis studies were about evenly split between students in college or earlier years of education and learners in graduate programs or professional training. The average learner age in a study ranged from 13 to 44. Intervention/Program/Practice: The meta-analysis was conducted on 50 effects found in 45 studies contrasting a fully or partially online condition with a fully face-to-face instructional condition. Length of instruction varied across studies and exceeded one month in the majority of them. Research Design: The meta-analysis corpus consisted of (1) experimental studies using random assignment and (2) quasi-experiments with statistical control for preexisting group differences. An effect size was calculated or estimated for each contrast, and average effect sizes were computed for fully online learning and for blended learning. A coding scheme was applied to classify each study in terms of a set of conditions, practices, and methodological variables. Findings/Results: The meta-analysis found that, on average, students in online learning conditions performed modestly better than those receiving face-to-face instruction. The advantage over face-to-face classes was significant in those studies contrasting blended learning with traditional face-to-face instruction but not in those studies contrasting purely online with face-to-face conditions. Conclusions/Recommendations: Studies using blended learning also tended to involve additional learning time, instructional resources, and course elements that encourage interactions among learners. This confounding leaves open the possibility that one or all of these other practice variables contributed to the particularly positive outcomes for blended learning. Further research and development on different blended learning models is warranted. Experimental research testing design principles for blending online and face-to-face instruction for different kinds of learners is needed.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Educating Generalist Physicians about Chronic Pain: Live Experts and Online Education Can Provide Durable BenefitsPain Medicine, 2008
- Effectiveness of e-learning in continuing medical education for occupational physiciansOccupational Medicine, 2008
- Evaluation of a Particle Repositioning Maneuver Web‐Based Teaching ModuleThe Laryngoscope, 2008
- Assessing the Success Rate of Students Using a Learning Management System Together with a Collaborative Tool in Web-Based Teaching of Programming LanguagesJournal of Educational Computing Research, 2007
- Comparing land combining real and virtual experimentation: an effort to enhance students' conceptual understanding of electric circuitsJournal of Computer Assisted Learning, 2007
- Scaffolding the Writing of Students with Disabilities through Procedural Facilitation: Using an Internet-Based Technology to Improve PerformanceLearning Disability Quarterly, 2007
- Technology‐based learning and the project managerEngineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 2004
- Are Computer-Assisted Teaching Methods Effective?Teaching of Psychology, 2004
- THE EFFECTS OF WORLD WIDE WEB INSTRUCTION AND TRADITIONAL INSTRUCTION AND LEARNING STYLES ON ACHIEVEMENT AND CHANGES IN STUDENT ATTITUDES IN A TECHNICAL WRITING IN AN AGRICOMMUNICATION COURSEJournal of Agricultural Education, 1998
- Reconsidering Research on Learning from MediaReview of Educational Research, 1983