A Primer on Anti‐Angling Philosophy and Its Relevance for Recreational Fisheries in Urbanized Societies
- 3 April 2012
- Vol. 37 (4), 153-164
- https://doi.org/10.1080/03632415.2012.666472
Abstract
In some industrialized countries, recreational fishing has come under moral pressure. To understand potential ramifications, we first describe three dominant philosophies of human‐animal interactions (i.e., animal welfare, animal liberation, and animal rights). We contend that, as long as fishing and handling practices are as fish friendly as possible, most animal welfare perspectives can easily accommodate recreational fishing in its present form. In contrast, animal liberation and animal rights philosophies tend to reject recreational fishing. On the hypothesis that economic development is conducive to the emergence of pro‐animal values in the wider public, it can be assumed that anti‐angling sentiments resonating strongly with animal liberation/rights thinking might increase. Examples from opinion surveys covering a range of countries show that about 25% of people already morally question recreational fishing for sport. Coupled with the supposed shift in pro‐animal values, this public sentiment might foster the implementation of regulations similar to those already seen in some European countries, which are imposed to constrain popular recreational angling practices such as the use of live baitfish or the release of legally harvestable fish. Increasing anti‐angling sentiments bolstered with arguments from animal liberation and rights can thus have far‐reaching consequences for recreational fisheries.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contrasting pragmatic and suffering‐centred approaches to fish welfare in recreational anglingJournal of Fish Biology, 2009
- Minnesota Anglers' Fisheries-Related Value Orientations and Their Stewardship of Fish ResourcesHuman Dimensions of Wildlife, 2008
- Anthropomorphism and ?mental welfare? of fishesDiseases of Aquatic Organisms, 2007
- Voluntary catch‐and‐release can generate conflict within the recreational angling community: a qualitative case study of specialised carp, Cyprinus carpio, angling in GermanyFisheries Management and Ecology, 2007
- Understanding the complexity of catch-and-release in recreational fishing: An integrative synthesis of global knowledge from historical, ethical, social, and biological perspectivesReviews in Fisheries Science, 2006
- Physiology, behaviour and welfare of fish during recreational fishing and after releaseNew Zealand Veterinary Journal, 2006
- An overview of surveys on how people view animal experimentation: some factors that may influence the outcomePublic Understanding of Science, 2003
- Wildlife value orientations: A conceptual and measurement approachHuman Dimensions of Wildlife, 1996
- Psychological Mechanisms in the Human Use of AnimalsJournal of Social Issues, 1993
- Humans' perceptions of animal mentality: Ascriptions of thinking..Journal of Comparative Psychology, 1993