REEXAMINING THE ROLE OF RECASTS IN SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION
Top Cited Papers
- 26 October 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Studies in Second Language Acquisition
- Vol. 28 (04), 575-600
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s027226310606027x
Abstract
Recasts have continued to be the object of intensive empirical and theoretical inquiry following Nicholas, Lightbown, and Spada's (2001) review. The current article identifies a number of problems with this research and the supporting theory. These problems concern the fact that recasts can take many different forms and perform a variety of functions (not all corrective), which makes definition difficult. Also, recasts, when corrective, can vary in terms of whether they constitute an implicit or explicit corrective strategy and in whether they afford negative or positive evidence. Researchers have almost exclusively examined recasts from a cognitive perspective, ignoring their social and sociocognitive aspects. The significance of learner repair following recasts also remains controversial. Little is currently known about the role that the learner's developmental readiness plays in determining whether recasts work for acquisition. Researchers have not clearly distinguished between intensive and extensive recasts, nor have they considered their differential benefits. The acquisitional value of recasts in comparison to other forms of corrective feedback might have been overestimated. This article emphasizes the need for research that examines the specific properties of recasts and the social and instructional conditions in which they occur.We would like to thank various people for their comments on draft versions of this article: Rob Batstone, Shawn Loewen, Alison Mackey, Jenefer Philp, Elaine Tarone, and two anonymous SSLA reviewers.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring the relationship between characteristics of recasts and learner uptakeLanguage Teaching Research, 2006
- The Effectiveness of Written Recasts in the Second Language Acquisition of Aspectual Distinctions in French: A Follow-Up StudyThe Modern Language Journal, 2004
- NEGATIVE FEEDBACK AND POSITIVE EVIDENCE IN TASK-BASED INTERACTIONStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2003
- Learner Awareness of Recasts in Classroom Interaction: A Case Study of an Adult EFL Student's Second Language LearningLanguage Awareness, 2002
- Patterns of Corrective Feedback and Uptake in an Adult ESL ClassroomTESOL Quarterly, 2002
- Sequencing in SLAStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1996
- Explicit and Implicit Negative FeedbackStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1993
- On Explicit and Negative Data Effecting and AffectingCompetenceandLinguistic BehaviorStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1993
- The Structural Syllabus and Second Language AcquisitionTESOL Quarterly, 1993
- The Effect of Error Correction on L2 Grammar Knowledge and Oral ProficiencyThe Modern Language Journal, 1993