Importance of tyrosine phosphatases in the effects of cell‐cell contact and microenvironments on EGF‐stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation

Abstract

We have compared the EGF responses of A431 cells when grown as monolayers at a variety of cell densities of as multicellular spheroids in order to investigate the effects of cell contact and 3-dimensional structure on signal transduction. Proliferation of the A431 squamous carcinoma cell line grown in our laboratory was unaffected by EGF when grown in monolayer culture. As 3-dimensional, multicellular spheroids, however, growth was stimulated by EGF. The maximum volume attainable in the presence of EGF was more than 30 times that in its absence. EGF-dependent tyrosine phosphorylation was compared under these conditions by immunohistochemistry and Western blotting. In initial experiments using published procedures, tyrosine phosphorylation was density-dependent in monolayers and undetectable in spheroids. However, the density-dependence was abolished by the addition of high concentrations of protein tyrosine phosphatase inhibitors (1 mM Zn⁺⁺ and VO₄³⁻). The density dependence of EGF-stimulated tyrosine phosphorylation in monolayers was, therefore, largely the result of changes in phosphatase activity rather than kinase. Using high concentrations of phosphatase inhibitors, phosphotyrosine was clearly visible by immunohistochemistry in the outermost cells of spheroids, but it was still not visible in the spheroid center. The lack of response within the spheroid was not related to the presence of EGF receptor nor diffusion of EGF. In companion experiments, we showed that staining for EGF receptor was present homogeneously throughout the spheroid and that EGF penetrated to its center under the conditions of the experiment. Thus, although an increase in tyrosine phosphatase activity was a major factor affecting tyrosine phosphorylation in the outer cells, other factors were important in the inner cells. We concluded that an increase of tyrosine phosphatase activity was the most important component of the adaptation of the EGF signal transduction system to high cell density in monolayer cultures. In spheroids, tyrosine phosphatases are also enhanced, but other factors, such as autocrine synthesis of TGF-α and possibly the cellular distribution of EGF receptors and cell shape, play a role.