Two Is Not Always Better Than One
- 1 November 2009
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Vol. 4 (6), 533-550
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6924.2009.01164.x
Abstract
Over the past two decades, there has been an upsurge in theoretical frameworks alluding to the existence of two different processing systems that supposedly operate according to different rules. This article critically examines the scientific advance offered by these theories (in particular advances in the domains of reasoning, decision making, and social cognition) and questions their theoretical coherence as well as the evidence for their existence. We scrutinize the conceptual underpinnings of two-system models and explicate the assumptions underlying these models to see whether they are reasonable. We also evaluate the empirical paradigms used to validate two-system models and ponder about their explanatory strength and predictive power. Given the popularity of these models, we discuss the appeal of two-system theories and suggest potential reasons for their prevalence. We comment on the potential costs associated with these models and allude to the desired nature of potential alternatives. We conclude that two-system models currently provide little scientific advance, and we encourage researchers to adopt more rigorous conceptual definitions and employ more stringent criteria for testing the empirical evidence in support for two-system theories.Keywords
This publication has 83 references indexed in Scilit:
- Neuroscientific Evidence About the Distinction Between Short- and Long-Term MemoryCurrent Directions in Psychological Science, 2008
- Frames, Biases, and Rational Decision-Making in the Human BrainScience, 2006
- Searching for commonalities in human judgement: The parametric unimodel and its dual mode alternativesEuropean Review of Social Psychology, 2003
- A simplicity principle in unsupervised human categorizationCognitive Science, 2002
- The dilemma with dichotomiesLanguage & Communication, 2001
- What do double dissociations prove?Cognitive Science, 2001
- Phi is not beta, and why Wertheimer’s discovery launched the Gestalt revolutionVision Research, 2000
- Persuasion by a Single Route: A View From the UnimodelPsychological Inquiry, 1999
- How do we tell an association from a rule? Comment on Sloman (1996).Psychological Bulletin, 1996
- Hearing lips and seeing voicesNature, 1976