Uses and Misuses of Multicriteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) in Environmental Decision Making
- 23 December 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Risk Analysis
- Vol. 29 (1), 26-33
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6924.2008.01130.x
Abstract
We focus on a class of multicriteria methods that are commonly used in environmental decision making—those that employ the weighted linear average algorithm (and this includes the popular analytic hierarchy process (AHP)). While we do not doubt the potential benefits of using formal decision methods of this type, we draw attention to the consequences of not using them well. In particular, we highlight a property of these methods that should not be overlooked when they are applied in environmental and wider decision-making contexts: the final decision or ranking of options is dependent on the choice of performance scoring scales for the criteria when the criteria weights are held constant. We compare this “sensitivity” to a well-known criticism of the AHP, and we go on to describe the more general lesson when it comes to using weighted linear average methods—a lesson concerning the relationship between criteria weights and performance scoring scales.This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- From comparative risk assessment to multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management: Recent developments and applicationsEnvironment International, 2006
- Incorporating multiple criteria into the design of conservation area networks: a minireview with recommendationsDiversity and Distributions, 2006
- Environmental conflicts and nature reserves: redesigning Sierra San Pedro Mártir National Park, MexicoBiological Conservation, 2004
- Identifying public preferences for land preservation using the analytic hierarchy processEcological Economics, 2002
- Interpretation of criteria weights in multicriteria decision makingComputers & Industrial Engineering, 1999
- Designing the buffer zone of a nature reserve: a case study in Yancheng Biosphere Reserve, ChinaBiological Conservation, 1999
- DESIGNING BIORESERVE NETWORKS TO SATISFY MULTIPLE, CONFLICTING DEMANDSEcological Applications, 1999
- Choosing between Alternative Farming Systems: An Application of the Analytic Hierarchy ProcessApplied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 1996
- SMARTS and SMARTER: Improved Simple Methods for Multiattribute Utility MeasurementOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1994
- RANK GENERATION, PRESERVATION, AND REVERSAL IN THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY DECISION PROCESSDecision Sciences, 1987