Suicide Determination and the Professional Authority of Medical Examiners
- 1 April 2005
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Sociological Review
- Vol. 70 (2), 311-333
- https://doi.org/10.1177/000312240507000206
Abstract
Since Durkheim's pioneering study, official suicide statistics have been suspected of underreporting the true suicide rate. A majority of researchers asserts that mistakes are minimal and not systematic while a minority claims that suicide statistics are systematically biased. Lingering uncertainties about suicide rate accuracy call into question the claims of scholarship and the efficacy of prevention programs. From the perspective of the sociology of professions, the critique of suicide accuracy challenges the professional authority of death investigators. Ethnographic observations show that medical examiners tend to underclassify suicides because the suicide classification requires positive proof of suicidal intent and because false negatives do not challenge the authority of medical examiners as much as false positives. Sufficient proof for suicide results from medical examiners' privileging of pathological evidence, the legal threshold to interpret evidence, and close relationships with law enforcement and clinicians. The same professional characteristics that safeguard forensic authority result in suicide underreporting: medical examiners protect their authority by determining suicide conservatively. Relatives acting to avoid the stigma of suicide and public health officials concerned with underreporting have a marginal influence on suicide determinations. This article contributes to the sociology of professions literature by analyzing how a professional group maintains authority in spite of profound criticism from outside parties.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Child fatality review: an international movementChild Abuse & Neglect, 2002
- Level of Agreement Between Opinions of Medical Examiner Investigators and Forensic Pathologist Medical Examiners Regarding the Manner of DeathAmerican Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology, 2000
- Medical Uncertainty RevisitedPublished by SAGE Publications ,2000
- Investigation and Review of Unexpected Infant and Child DeathsPublished by American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) ,1999
- Mind Your MannersAmerican Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology, 1997
- Lawsuits Against Medical Examiners or Coroners Arising From Death CertificatesAmerican Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology, 1997
- Under-reporting of suicide in Ireland 1960-1989Archives of Suicide Research, 1997
- Dynamics of Professional Control: Internal Coalitions and Crossprofessional BoundariesAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1992
- The System of ProfessionsPublished by University of Chicago Press ,1988
- The Problematic Death CertificateNew England Journal of Medicine, 1985