Psychiatric diagnosis – is it universal or relative to culture?
- 7 March 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
- Vol. 49 (3), 237-250
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7610.2007.01854.x
Abstract
Background: There is little consensus on the extent to which psychiatric disorders or syndromes are universal or the extent to which they differ on their core definitions and constellation of symptoms as a result of cultural or contextual factors. This controversy continues due to the lack of biological markers, imprecise measurement and the lack of a gold standard for validating most psychiatric conditions. Method: Empirical studies were used to present evidence in favor of or against a universalist or relativistic view of child psychiatric disorders using a model developed by Robins and Guze to determine the validity of psychiatric disorders. Results: The prevalence of some of the most common specific disorders and syndromes as well as its risk and protective factors vary across cultures, yet comorbid patterns and response to treatments vary little across cultures. Cross-cultural longitudinal data on outcomes is equivocal. Conclusions: The cross-cultural validity of child disorders may vary drastically depending on the disorder, but empirical evidence that attests for the cross-cultural validity of diagnostic criteria for each child disorder is lacking. There is a need for studies that investigate the extent to which gene–environment interactions are related to specific disorders across cultures. Clinicians are urged to consider culture and context in determining the way in which children's psychopathology may be manifested independent of their views. Recommendations for the upcoming classificatory system are provided so that practical or theoretical considerations are addressed about how culture and ethnic issues affect the assessment or treatment of specific disorders in children.Keywords
This publication has 119 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prevalence and correlates of eating disorders in Latinos in the United StatesInternational Journal of Eating Disorders, 2007
- Ethnicity and Risk of Psychiatric Disorder Among AdolescentsResearch in Human Development, 2007
- The McGill Illness Narrative Interview (MINI): An Interview Schedule to Elicit Meanings and Modes of Reasoning Related to Illness ExperienceTranscultural Psychiatry, 2006
- Anthropology in the Clinic: The Problem of Cultural Competency and How to Fix ItPLoS Medicine, 2006
- Genetic and Environmental Influences on Temperament in the First Year of Life: The Puerto Rico Infant Twin Study (PRINTS)Twin Research and Human Genetics, 2005
- Cross-cultural Similarities in ADHD-Like Behaviour Amongst South African Primary School ChildrenSouth African Journal of Psychology, 2004
- Testing hypotheses on specific environmental causal effects on behavior.Psychological Bulletin, 2001
- Evolutionary versus prototype analyses of the concept of disorder.Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 1999
- The adaptation and testing of diagnostic and outcome measures for cross-cultural researchInternational Review of Psychiatry, 1994
- Family preservation using multisystemic therapy: An effective alternative to incarcerating serious juvenile offenders.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1992