National survey of the current management of endometriomas in women undergoing assisted reproductive treatment

Abstract

What is the current management of women with ovarian endometriomas undergoing assisted reproductive treatment (ART) in the UK? It appears that the majority of gynaecologists in the UK offer surgery (mostly cystectomy) for endometriomas prior to ART, regardless of the presence of symptoms. The ideal management of endometriomas in women undergoing ART remains controversial and presents a dilemma to reproductive specialists. This was a national cross-sectional survey. A total of 388 gynaecologists completed the questionnaire. All clinicians fully registered with the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists were contacted. An 11-item survey was administered electronically using Survey Monkey software. Quantitative data were analysed using descriptive and comparative statistics. The majority of responders were consultants (65%), 25% practiced ART and 65% performed laparoscopic surgery. Overall, 95% of responders would offer surgery for endometriomas in women undergoing ART, either on the basis of the size (>3–5 cm) of the endometrioma (52%), the presence of symptoms (16%), the presence of multiple/bilateral endometriomas (2%), regardless of the size and symptoms (19%) or only to women undergoing IVF (6%). The remaining 5% of responders would not offer surgery before ART. Excision was the most common surgical modality (68%), followed by ablation (25%). Laparoscopic surgeons were almost twice as likely to ‘offer surgery to all patients with endometriomas prior to ART’ compared with clinicians performing laparotomy (22 versus 12%, P < 0.001). Our overall response rate, with answers to the questionnaire, was low (15%). However, the response rate amongst reproductive specialists was estimated at 60%. It is possible that there might have been an element of bias towards over-representation of responders who are more concerned about ‘normalization’ of the pelvic anatomy. Furthermore, our survey relied on self-reporting of practice and it is possible that being presented with a list of ‘ideal’ options may have resulted in respondent bias. Despite the available evidence that surgery for endometriomas does not improve the outcome of ART and may damage ovarian reserve, it seems that the majority of gynaecologists in the UK offer ovarian cystectomy to their patients. None.