Peridural Anesthesia or Ultrasound-Guided Continuous 3-in-1 Block
Open Access
- 1 September 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Geriatric Orthopaedic Surgery & Rehabilitation
- Vol. 3 (3), 121-128
- https://doi.org/10.1177/2151458512470953
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of our study was to investigate the clinical relevance of preoperative acute pain management and cardiovascular stability by ultrasound-guided continuous 3-in-1 nerve block in very elderly patients with hip fracture when compared to epidural anesthesia (PDA). Methods: To study the analgesic effect, we enrolled 37 very elderly patients with hip fractures, of whom 3 patients with dementia had to be excluded. Thus, 34 patients were randomized to 1 of the 3 groups: group A (ultrasound-guided continuous 3-in-1 block, bupivacaine; n = 10, dropout rate: 0), group B (PDA, bupivacaine; n = 14, dropout rate: 8), and group C (systemic pain therapy, piritramide/paracetamol; n = 10, dropout rate: 0). Pain intensity was assessed preoperatively and up to 24 hours postoperatively using a visual analog scale, verbal rating scale, analgesic consumption, scale of well-being, and cardiocirculatory parameters (eg, serum troponin T). Results: Our data show that in the preoperative period both regional anesthesia (RA) procedures (analgesia responders after 1 hour: 86.7% and 100%; P = .001) were superior to systemic analgesia (analgesia responders: 46.7%), and the rescue medication requirement in the 2 RA groups was significantly lower ( P = .02). Serum troponin T level increased only in the systemic analgesia group ( P = .04). In the emergency department, the disadvantage of PDA in geriatric patients with hip fracture was the fact that procedures were more complex, resulting in a high dropout rate (57.1%). The use of PDA has to be critically discussed for ethical concerns. Conclusion: In the specific situation of acute hospital admission, the ultrasound-guided continuous 3-in-1 block appears to be indicated as a stress-free means of providing adequate preoperative pain relief in very elderly patients with hip fracture. However, these findings should be corroborated by studies involving larger numbers of patients.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of early surgery after hip fracture on mortality and complications: systematic review and meta-analysisCMAJ : Canadian Medical Association Journal, 2010
- Reporting bias in medical research - a narrative reviewTrials, 2010
- Geriatric Co‐Management of Proximal Femur Fractures: Total Quality Management and Protocol‐Driven Care Result in Better Outcomes for a Frail Patient PopulationJournal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2008
- Effects of Intravenous Patient-Controlled Analgesia With Morphine, Continuous Epidural Analgesia, and Continuous Femoral Nerve Sheath Block on Rehabilitation After Unilateral Total-Hip ArthroplastyRegional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine, 2005
- Use of Serial Mini‐Mental State Examinations to Diagnose and Monitor Delirium in Elderly Hospital PatientsJournal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2005
- The Role of Epidural Anesthesia and Analgesia in Surgical PracticeAnnals of Surgery, 2003
- Regional nerve block in fractured neck of femurEmergency Medicine Journal, 2002
- A randomized controlled double-blind trial comparing piritramide and morphine for analgesia after hysterectomyEuropean Journal of Anaesthesiology, 2001
- Nerve stimulator-assisted femoral nerve block in the emergency departmentEmergency Medicine Australasia, 2000
- The femoral 3-in-1 block revisitedJournal of Clinical Anesthesia, 1993