Restrictions on addition: children's interpretation of the focus particles auch ‘also’ and nur ‘only’ in German
- 27 July 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Child Language
- Vol. 39 (2), 383-410
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0305000911000122
Abstract
Children up to school age have been reported to perform poorly when interpreting sentences containing restrictive and additive focus particles by treating sentences with a focus particle in the same way as sentences without it. Careful comparisons between results of previous studies indicate that this phenomenon is less pronounced for restrictive than for additive particles. We argue that this asymmetry is an effect of the presuppositional status of the proposition triggered by the additive particle. We tested this in two experiments with German-learning three- and four-year-olds using a method that made the exploitation of the information provided by the particles highly relevant for completing the task. Three-year-olds already performed remarkably well with sentences both with auch ‘also’ and with nur ‘only’. Thus, children can consider the presuppositional contribution of the additive particle in their sentence interpretation and can exploit the restrictive particle as a marker of exhaustivity.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Production/comprehension asymmetries in language acquisitionLingua, 2010
- Over-informative children: Production/comprehension asymmetry or tolerance to pragmatic violations?Lingua, 2010
- Focus identification in child MandarinJournal of Child Language, 2009
- Children's Interpretation of Focus Expressions in English and MandarinLanguage Acquisition, 2009
- Information structural constraints on children’s early language production: The acquisition of the focus particle auch (‘also’) in German-learning 12- to 36-month-oldsFirst Language, 2009
- Presupposition and Anaphora: Remarks on the Formulation of the Projection ProblemLinguistic Inquiry, 2009
- Focus Particles in Children's Language: Production and Comprehension ofAuch‘Also’ in German Learners from 1 Year to 4 Years of AgeLanguage Acquisition, 2009
- WHAT IS PRESUPPOSITION ACCOMMODATION, AGAIN?*Philosophical Perspectives, 2008
- Scalar implicatures: experiments at the semantics–pragmatics interfaceCognition, 2003
- The Meaning of Focus Particles: A Comparative PerspectiveLanguage, 1993