Penal subversions: When is a punishment not punishment, who decides and on what grounds?
Open Access
- 13 August 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Theoretical Criminology
- Vol. 20 (1), 3-20
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1362480615598830
Abstract
Current criminological interest in the boundaries of penality has done much to shed light on the definition and meaning of punishment. Even the central case of punishment, its aims and purposes are contested, so it should not surprise that the boundaries are also disputed. As states seek to evade the criminal process and its protections by resort to civil and administrative measures, the line between formal and informal criminal penalties blurs. In Europe, the courts have sought to reassert the protections of the criminal process by looking behind the labels to insist on substance over form in deciding what is a punishment. In so doing, they have re-affirmed the boundaries of penality as a vital means of providing protection against arbitrary government. Examining these turf wars reveals a constitutional struggle over the very authority of the state to punish.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Penal Boundaries: Banishment and the Expansion of PunishmentLaw & Social Inquiry, 2010
- WHY ONLY THE STATE MAY INFLICT CRIMINAL SANCTIONS: THE CASE AGAINST PRIVATELY INFLICTED SANCTIONSLegal Theory, 2008
- Punishment and RepentancePhilosophy, 2006
- Beyond white man's justiceTheoretical Criminology, 2006
- "IT'S GETTING CRAZY OUT THERE": CAN A CIVIL GANG INJUNCTION CHANGE A COMMUNITY?*Criminology & Public Policy, 2005
- The Truth in Autonomous Concepts: How To Interpret the ECHREuropean Journal of International Law, 2004
- Punishing Dangerousness: Cloaking Preventive Detention as Criminal JusticeHarvard Law Review, 2001
- Civil Banishment of Gang Members: Circumventing Criminal Due Process Requirements?The University of Chicago Law Review, 2000
- Regulatory enforcement in the presence of a court systemInternational Review of Law and Economics, 1997
- OVERLAPPING TENSIONS BETWEEN CRIMINAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW: THE EXPERIENCE OF WEST GERMAN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW†Journal of Environmental Law, 1991