History of Innovative Best Management Practice Development and its Role in Addressing Water Quality Limited Waterbodies

Abstract

Best management practices (BMPs) are practical control measures (including technological, economic, and institutional considerations) that have been demonstrated to effectively minimize water quality impacts. The use of BMPs is widely accepted as the most appropriate method of controlling nonpoint sources of pollution because BMPs prevent or minimize pollution rather than retrospectively respond to it. Still, there is a stigma that BMPs do not afford quite the same degree of protection or assurance of pollution control that effluent treatment and process controls do for point sources. Here we provide a brief history of BMPs and their emergence as a practical water pollution control tool for nonpoint source activities, with a focus on the history of forestry BMPs. This history demonstrates the variety of BMPs used to avoid or minimize the generation of nonpoint source pollutants or reduce delivery of these materials to streams. It also demonstrates the extensive testing of BMP effectiveness that has been conducted throughout the United States. Those who must select or design BMPs face difficult issues about balancing desirable and undesirable inputs of watershed materials and energy to streams. We show that BMPs and nonpoint source control programs are not a “weak sister” of effluent treatment and point source control efforts, and are effectively addressing extremely complex and variable watershed conditions. Best management practices continue to evolve as research identifies new environmental concerns and control options and, as the primary tool for controlling nonpoint source pollution, play a key role in addressing water quality limited waterbodies.