Precision and accuracy of three alternative instruments for measuring soil water content in two forest soils of the Pacific Northwest
- 1 August 2005
- journal article
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Canadian Journal of Forest Research
- Vol. 35 (8), 1867-1876
- https://doi.org/10.1139/x05-121
Abstract
We compared the accuracy and precision of three devices for measuring soil water content in both natural and repacked soils and evaluated their temperature sensitivity. Calibrations were developed for a capacitance instrument (ECH2O), a time domain reflectometry cable tester (CT), and a water content reflectometer (WCR) in soils collected from the Wind River and H.J. Andrews Experimental Forests. We compared these calibrations with equations suggested by manufacturers or commonly used in the literature and found the standard equations predicted soil moisture content 0%–11.5% lower (p < 0.0001) than new calibrations. Each new calibration equation adequately predicted soil moisture from the output for each instrument regardless of location or soil type. Prediction intervals varied, with errors of 4.5%, 3.5%, and 7.1% for the ECH2O, CT, and WCR, respectively. Only the ECH2O system was significantly influenced by temperature for the range sampled: as temperature increased by 1 °C, the soil moisture estimate decreased by 0.1%. Overall, the ECH2O performed nearly as well as the CT, and thanks to its lower cost, small differences in performance might be offset by deployment of a greater number of probes in field sampling. Despite its higher cost, the WCR did not perform as well as the other two systems.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Texture and Electrical Conductivity Effects on Temperature Dependency in Time Domain ReflectometrySoil Science Society of America Journal, 1998
- COAXIAL MULTIPLEXER FOR TIME DOMAIN REFLECTOMETRY MEASUREMENT OF SOILWATER CONTENT AND BULK ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITYTransactions of the ASAE, 1998
- Real‐time Soil Water Dynamics Using Multisensor Capacitance Probes: Laboratory CalibrationSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1997
- Water content measurement in forest soils and decayed wood using time domain reflectometryCanadian Journal of Forest Research, 1995
- Temperature‐Dependent Measurement Errors in Time Domain Reflectometry Determinations of Soil WaterSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1995
- A laboratory calibration of time domain reflectometry for soil water measurement including effects of bulk density and textureJournal of Hydrology, 1993
- Improved Calibration of Time Domain Reflectometry Soil Water Content MeasurementsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1993
- Remote Diode Shorting Improves Measurement of Soil Water by Time Domain ReflectometrySoil Science Society of America Journal, 1992
- Sensitivity of time domain reflectometry measurements to lateral variations in soil water contentWater Resources Research, 1992
- Soil moisture measurement by an improved capacitance technique, Part I. Sensor design and performanceJournal of Hydrology, 1987