Human control of an inverted pendulum: Is continuous control necessary? Is intermittent control effective? Is intermittent control physiological?
- 14 January 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal Of Physiology-London
- Vol. 589 (2), 307-324
- https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2010.194712
Abstract
Human motor control is often explained in terms of engineering 'servo' theory. Recently, continuous, optimal control using internal models has emerged as a leading paradigm for voluntary movement. However, these engineering paradigms are designed for high band-width, inflexible, consistent systems whereas human control is low bandwidth and flexible using noisy sensors and actuators. By contrast, engineering intermittent control was designed for bandwidth-limited applications. Our general interest is whether intermittent rather than continuous control is generic to human motor control. Currently, it would be assumed that continuous control is the superior and physiologically natural choice for controlling unstable loads, for example as required for maintaining human balance. Using visuo-manual tracking of an unstable load, we show that control using gentle, intermittent taps is entirely natural and effective. The gentle tapping method resulted in slightly superior position control and velocity minimisation, a reduced feedback time delay, greater robustness to changing actuator gain and equal or greater linearity with respect to the external disturbance. Control was possible with a median contact rate of 0.8±0.3 s(-1). However, when optimising position or velocity regulation, a modal contact rate of 2 s(-1) was observed. This modal rate was consistent with insignificant disturbance-joystick coherence beyond 1-2 Hz in both tapping and continuous contact methods. For this load, these results demonstrate a motor control process of serial ballistic trajectories limited to an optimum rate of 2 s(-1). Consistent with theoretical reasoning, our results suggest that intermittent open loop action is a natural consequence of human physiology.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Changes of mind in decision-makingNature, 2009
- Visual control of stable and unstable loads: what is the feedback delay and extent of linear time‐invariant control?Journal Of Physiology-London, 2009
- Identification of the Plant for Upright Stance in Humans: Multiple Movement Patterns From a Single Neural StrategyJournal of Neurophysiology, 2008
- Mere Expectation to Move Causes Attenuation of Sensory SignalsPLOS ONE, 2008
- Noise in the nervous systemNature Reviews Neuroscience, 2008
- The passive, human calf muscles in relation to standing: the short range stiffness lies in the contractile componentJournal Of Physiology-London, 2007
- Computational principles of sensorimotor control that minimize uncertainty and variabilityJournal Of Physiology-London, 2007
- The frequency of human, manual adjustments in balancing an inverted pendulum is constrained by intrinsic physiological factorsJournal Of Physiology-London, 2006
- Manually controlled human balancing using visual, vestibular and proprioceptive senses involves a common, low frequency neural processJournal Of Physiology-London, 2006
- Attenuation of Self-Generated Tactile Sensations Is Predictive, not PostdictivePLoS Biology, 2006