Effectiveness in social impact assessment: Aboriginal peoples and resource development in Australia
- 1 June 2009
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal
- Vol. 27 (2), 95-110
- https://doi.org/10.3152/146155109x438715
Abstract
Definitions of and judgments regarding effectiveness in social impact assessment (SIA) depend on how the activities that constitute SIA, and the purposes of SIA, are understood. The latter, in particular, are defined differently by various groups and interests that participate in, or are affected by, impact assessment processes. Thus the concept of 'effectiveness', and the issue of what is required to achieve it, are both contested and contextual. This article reviews a number of different approaches to SIA, and outlines in general terms what effectiveness might mean for each. It then considers, at two levels, what 'effective SIA' involves in a specific context, that of large-scale resource development on the traditional lands of Australia's Aboriginal peoples. The first level involves control of SIA. For indigenous peoples who have historically been excluded from and ignored by SIAs undertaken as part of government approval processes, Aboriginal control of SIA is an essential prerequisite for 'effective SIA'. However control only creates the potential for effectiveness. The second level of analysis involves the numerous practical activities that must be undertaken, and issues that must be addressed, to realise this potential. The paper develops a matrix designed to help practitioners and affected indigenous groups identify and manage these activities and issues in a systematic way. Many of them are also relevant in conducting SIA in non-indigenous contexts, and so the analysis is of wider application.Griffith Business School, School of Government and International RelationsFull TexKeywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contentious politics in environmental assessment: blocked projects and winning coalitionsImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2008
- The Contribution of Environmental Assessment to Sustainable Development: Toward a Richer Empirical UnderstandingEnvironmental Management, 2007
- Time for a new approach to public participation in EA: Promoting cooperation and consensus for sustainabilityEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2006
- The interminable issue of effectiveness: substantive purposes, outcomes and research challenges in the advancement of environmental impact assessment theoryImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2004
- Evaluating the effectiveness of British Columbia's environmental assessment process for first nations' participation in mining developmentEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2003
- Social impact assessmentEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2001
- The effectiveness of provisions and quality of practices concerning public participation in EIA in ItalyEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2000
- Adapting environmental impact assessment to sustain the community development processHabitat International, 1996
- Social impact assessment: Politically oriented approaches and applicationsEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 1990
- Anthropology and impact assessment: Development pressures and indigenous interests in AustraliaEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 1990