The Universal and the Contextual of Media Systems: Research Design, Epistemology, and the Production of Comparative Knowledge
- 21 April 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The International Journal of Press/Politics
- Vol. 23 (2), 143-160
- https://doi.org/10.1177/1940161218771899
Abstract
Current discussions about the state of comparative research in journalism studies and political communication suggests the field is characterized by a methodological imbalance (i.e., many quantitative studies, few qualitative ones). This paper suggests the problem is better understood as an epistemological imbalance. We suggest that one epistemology—we call it “universalism”—underpins much comparative scholarship. While this approach produces numerous comparative insights, it also struggles to adequately account for the diversity of contexts it studies. We therefore describe an alternative epistemology, which we term “contextualism.” This approach aims to identify the mechanisms or principles that unify or differentiate cases across contexts. We suggest that progress in the field depends in part on the coexistence of multiple epistemologies, each with careful awareness of its strengths and limitations.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- No alternative to austerity: how BBC broadcast news reported the deficit debateMedia, Culture & Society, 2016
- Hallin and Mancini Revisited: Four Empirical Types of Western Media SystemsJournal of Communication, 2014
- Frequency or SkillfulnessJournalism Studies, 2014
- Exposing Politicians’ Peccadilloes in Comparative Context: Explaining the Frequency of Political Sex Scandals in Eight Democracies Using Fuzzy Set Qualitative Comparative AnalysisPolitical Communication, 2013
- Reviewing key concepts in research on political news journalism: Conceptualizations, operationalizations, and propositions for future researchJournalism, 2012
- Understanding Process TracingPS: Political Science and Politics, 2011
- MAPPING JOURNALISM CULTURES ACROSS NATIONSJournalism Studies, 2011
- Media Systems and the Political Information Environment: A Cross-National ComparisonThe International Journal of Press/Politics, 2010
- Comparative Political Communications: Common Frameworks or Babelian Confusion?Government and Opposition, 2009
- Odious Comparisons: Incommensurability, the Case Study, and “Small N's” in SociologySociological Theory, 2004