Beyond Metaphor: Mathematical Models in Economics as Empirical Research
- 1 January 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Science in Context
- Vol. 12 (2), 317-332
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0269889700003446
Abstract
The Argument When economists report on research using mathematical models, they use a literary form similar to the experimental report in the laboratory sciences. This form consists of a narrative of a series of events, with a clear temporal segregation of the agency of the author and the agency of the objects of study. Existing explanations of this literary form treat it as a rhetorical device that either conceals the agency of the author in constructing and interpreting the findings, or simply appropriates the appearance of accepted (natural-)scientific method. This article — based on analysis of a research program in economics, a single article that issued from that program, and in-depth interviews with the authors — proposes an alternate interpretation. Drawing on the praxeological “laboratory studies” tradition in science studies, we treat work with mathematical models as involving the interaction of economists with objects (models) that act independently of the analyst's will. The clear separation of the economist's and the models agency, as depicted in the published report, is not the result of a rhetorical rewriting of actual events, but is a practical accomplishment. Every step in the analytical work that preceded the paper is devoted to developing a procedure in which the economists' agency will be completely accountable in terms of accepted practices, and the performance of the model will be distinct and compelling.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deconstruction in a `Thinking' Science: Theoretical Physicists at WorkSocial Studies of Science, 1997
- The Mangle of PracticePublished by University of Chicago Press ,1995
- The Statistical Turn in American Social Science: Columbia University, 1890 to 1915American Sociological Review, 1994
- So what's an economic metaphor?Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,1994
- Knowledge and Persuasion in EconomicsPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,1994
- Protection For SalePublished by National Bureau of Economic Research ,1992
- Formalism in the social sciences, rhetorically speakingThe American Sociologist, 1990
- Experiment and the Making of MeaningPublished by Springer Science and Business Media LLC ,1990
- More Heat than LightPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,1989
- Textual Persuasion: The Role of Social Accounting in the Construction of Scientific ArgumentsPhilosophy of the Social Sciences, 1981