Does it Matter Which Exercise?
- 1 December 2004
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health) in Spine
- Vol. 29 (23), 2593-2602
- https://doi.org/10.1097/01.brs.0000146464.23007.2a
Abstract
Multicentered randomized controlled trial. To determine if previously validated low back pain (LBP) subgroups respond differently to contrasting exercise prescriptions. The role of "patient-specific" exercises in managing LBP is controversial. A total of 312 acute, subacute, and chronic patients, including LBP-only and sciatica, underwent a standardized mechanical assessment classifying them by their pain response, specifically eliciting either a "directional preference" (DP) (i.e., an immediate, lasting improvement in pain from performing either repeated lumbar flexion, extension, or sideglide/rotation tests), or no DP. Only DP subjects were randomized to: 1) directional exercises "matching" their preferred direction (DP), 2) exercises directionally "opposite" their DP, or 3) "nondirectional" exercises. Outcome measures included pain intensity, location, disability, medication use, degree of recovery, depression, and work interference. A DP was elicited in 74% (230) of subjects. One third of both the opposite and non-directionally treated subjects withdrew within 2 weeks because of no improvement or worsening (no matched subject withdrew). Significantly greater improvements occurred in matched subjects compared with both other treatment groups in every outcome (P values <0.001), including a threefold decrease in medication use. Consistent with prior evidence, a standardized mechanical assessment identified a large subgroup of LBP patients with a DP. Regardless of subjects' direction of preference, the response to contrasting exercise prescriptions was significantly different: exercises matching subjects' DP significantly and rapidly decreased pain and medication use and improved in all other outcomes. If repeatable, such subgroup validation has important implications for LBP management.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Relation Between Pain Intensity, Disability, and the Episodic Nature of Chronic and Recurrent Low Back PainSpine, 2000
- The Role of Activity in the Therapeutic Management of Back PainSpine, 2000
- Management of Nonspecific Low Back Pain by Physiotherapists in Britain and IrelandSpine, 1999
- A Report From the Second International Forum for Primary Care Research on Low Back PainSpine, 1998
- A Prospective Study of Centralization of Lumbar and Referred PainSpine, 1997
- Intertester Reliability of McKenzieʼs Classifications of the Syndrome Types Present in Patients with Low Back PainSpine, 1993
- The Reliability of Back Pain Assessment by Physiotherapists, Using a ‘McKenzie Algorithm’Physiotherapy, 1990
- Chapter 3Spine, 1987
- The Use of Lumbar Extension in the Evaluation and Treatment of Patients With Acute Herniated Nucleus PulposusPublished by Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health) ,1986
- A Study of the Natural History of Back PainSpine, 1983