Political Conflict and Lesson-Drawing
- 1 January 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Public Policy
- Vol. 11 (1), 55-78
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0143814x00004931
Abstract
Political adversaries have reason and opportunity to use foreign lessons to gain advantage in political conflicts. Political factors strongly affect the way public policy lessons are drawn and transformed into public policy. Political opponents contest the value, practicality, and transferability of policy initiatives in order to bias the outcome. The paper hypothesizes that (i) the politicization of lesson-drawing induces issue experts to emphasize the descriptive and technical aspects of programs; (2) gives an incentive to advocates of change to use lessons to advance their position during the agenda-setting process; and (3) gives opponents of change an incentive to draw counterbalancing negative lessons from foreign experience when a proposed lesson reaches the point where adoption is entirely possible. The 1988 Congressional debate over mandatory plant closing prenotification provides evidence supporting hypotheses. The paper further hypothesizes: (4) most polities will not adopt both conservative and liberal programs even when theoretically they could do so; and (5) the degree to which a population of polities adopt a particular lesson will be a function of the program's economic and politicial feasibility. The diffusion of labor market and income maintenance policies across the American states supports both of these claims.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Democracy and MarketsPublished by Cornell University Press ,2019
- Inheritance Before Choice in Public policyJournal of Theoretical Politics, 1990
- State Lottery Adoptions as Policy Innovations: An Event History AnalysisAmerican Political Science Review, 1990
- Gumbo Politics: Unions, Business, and Louisiana Right-to-Work LegislationILR Review, 1990
- Gumbo Politics: Unions, Business, and Louisiana Right-to-Work LegislationILR Review, 1990
- State Political Culture and Public OpinionAmerican Political Science Review, 1987
- Policy Diffusion and Program Scope: Research DirectionsPublished by Crossref ,1985
- Diffusion Research Traditions and the Spread of Policy Innovations in a Federal SystemPublished by Crossref ,1985
- Prerequisites Versus Diffusion: Testing Alternative Explanations of Social Security AdoptionAmerican Political Science Review, 1975
- The Diffusion of Innovations among the American StatesAmerican Political Science Review, 1969