Effectiveness of USDA instrument-based marbling measurements for categorizing beef carcasses according to differences in longissimus muscle sensory attributes1
- 1 February 2013
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Animal Science
- Vol. 91 (2), 1024-1034
- https://doi.org/10.2527/jas.2012-5514
Abstract
This study quantified relationships between USDA instrument marbling measurements and LM sensory attributes (tenderness, flavor, juiciness), and shear force. Heifer (n = 390) and steer (n = 328) carcasses (all A-maturity) were selected at 4 beef processing plants in Colorado, Kansas, Nebraska, and Texas to represent 7 marbling degrees: traces (TR), slight (SL), small (SM), modest (MT), moderate (MD), slightly abundant (SA), and moderately abundant (MA). Classification into marbling groups was based on marbling scores determined using USDA-approved VBG 2000 grading systems. Strip loin steaks were obtained from both sides of each carcass and aged for 14 d. One steak was used to obtain Warner-Bratzler shear force (WBSF) and slice shear force (SSF) measurements. The other steak was evaluated by a trained sensory panel for juiciness, tenderness, intensity of flavors characterized as meaty/brothy, buttery/beef fat, bloody/serumy, livery/organy, and grassy; and overall sensory experience (negative or positive). Instrument marbling score explained 45%, 40%, 32%, 71%, and 61% of the observed variation in panel ratings for juiciness, tenderness, meaty/brothy flavor intensity, buttery/beef fat flavor intensity, and overall sensory experience, respectively. Increased degree of marbling resulted in steaks having greater (P < 0.001) juiciness (MA > SA > MD > MT > SM > SL = TR), meaty/brothy flavor (MA = SA > MD = MT > SM > SL > TR), and buttery/beef fat flavor (MA > SA > MD > MT > SM > SL > TR). Steak tenderness also increased (P < 0.001) as marbling degree increased; however, tenderness differences among marbling degrees differed for steers (MA = SA > MD = MT > SM > SL = TR) and heifers (MA = SA > MD > MT > SM > SL > TR). Steaks produced by steers had lower (P < 0.05) WBSF and SSF values, and were rated as more tender by sensory panelists than steaks produced by heifers, but the effect of sex on panel tenderness was significant only among steaks with TR marbling. Results of this study showed that instrument-based classification of beef carcasses, according to differences in marbling, effectively identified subsequent differences in strip loin steak sensory performance. Nearly all (98 to 99%) steaks with MA or SA marbling, and most (between 80% and 90%) steaks with MD and MT marbling, received positive ratings for overall sensory experience. In comparison, 62% of SM steaks, 29% of SL steaks, and 15% of TR steaks received positive sensory experience ratings. Copyright © 2013. American Society of Animal Science .Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prediction of fat percentage within marbling score on beef longissimus muscle using 3 different fat determination methods1Journal of Animal Science, 2011
- Efficacy of performing Warner–Bratzler and slice shear force on the same beef steak following rapid cookingMeat Science, 2010
- National Beef Quality Audit–2005: Survey of targeted cattle and carcass characteristics related to quality, quantity, and value of fed steers and heifers1Journal of Animal Science, 2008
- The effects of cattle sex on carcass characteristics and longissimus muscle palatability1,2Journal of Animal Science, 2006
- An evaluation of the USDA standards for feeder cattle frame size and muscle thickness.Journal of Animal Science, 2002
- Variation of residual glycogen-glucose concentration at ultimate pH values below 5.75Meat Science, 2000
- The usefulness of muscle color and pH for segregating beef carcasses into tenderness groupsMeat Science, 1991
- Flavor Constituents of Beef as Influenced by Forage‐ and Grain‐FeedingJournal of Food Science, 1987
- PREDICTIVE VALUE OF USDA BEEF QUALITY GRADE FACTORS FOR COOKED MEAT PALATABILITYJournal of Food Science, 1975
- An Evaluation of the Tenderometer for Measuring Beef TendernessJournal of Animal Science, 1974