Long‐Term Stability of Class II Furcation Defects Treated With Barrier Membranes

Abstract

The present longitudinal study was designed to explore the long-term efficacy of guided tissue regeneration (GTR) in Class II furcation defects and establish the factors that might be responsible for modifying this response. Subjects with two or more mandibular molars, one of which had Class II furcation defects, received the hygienic phase of therapy followed by baseline clinical measurements and subgingival plaque sampling. GTR procedure was performed in furcation defect sites using expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) membranes, while the other non-furcated molars received only scaling and root planning. Twenty-eight subjects (13 females, 15 males) aged 27 to 66 were included in this longitudinal analysis. Post-surgical treatment included routine home care supplemented with daily chlohexidine rinse and systemic tetracycline. Membranes were retrieved 4 to 6 weeks after surgery. During the first year, patients were initially seen bi-weekly and subsequently monthly for professional prophylaxis. At the end of this year, clinical measurements and samples were obtained. For the next 2 years, patients were seen bi-annually for maintenance visits. Clinical measurements and microbiological samples were then repeated. Next, a tighter maintenance protocol was established and patients were seen quarterly for scaling and oral hygiene reinforcement. Final measurements and samples were taken again 1 year later (4 years postoperative). Significant probing reduction (3.00 mm) and gain in horizontal attachment (2.59 mm) were obtained 1 year postsurgery for the GTR sites. These changes were maintained over 4 years with a slight decline at the end of year 3. Changes in probing depth (PD) from year 1 to 4 served to dichotomize the sites into stable (delta PD < or = 0.9 mm), and unstable (PD increase > or = 1 mm). Of the 54 sites available for this analysis only 5 (9.3%) were unstable while 49 (90.7%) were stable or even further improved. Sites which exhibited minimal or no plaque (plaque index [PI] < or = 1) over the tight maintenance period had a further decrease in mean probing depth (0.43 mm) compared with a slight increase (-0.06 mm) in mean probing depth in sites with PI > or = 2 mm (P = 0.0235). The same phenomenon was observed for changes in relative attachment level (RAL): mean gain in RAL was 0.61 mm compared to 0.25 mm for the 2 groups, respectively (P = 0.07). Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans was only isolated from 2 sites at year 3, and none at year 4, compared to 21.45% of the sites at baseline. Porphyromonas gingivalis positive sites showed a continual decline over the years: 14.28% at baseline, 10.71% at year 1, and 5.1% at year 4. On the contrary, Prevotella intermedia (Pi) and Bacteroides forsythus (Bf) infected sites remained at approximately the same rate throughout the 4 years of the study (40% to 50% and 30% to 40% for Pi and Bf, respectively). Of these, Pi-infected sites exhibited less favorable clinical results compared to sites which were not infected with this microorganism. In summary, furcation defects treated with membrane barriers can be maintained in health for at least 4 years; however, good oral hygiene and frequent recall visits as part of a complete anti-infective therapy are essential. Finally, once treated, these teeth are comparable to similar molar teeth with no previous history of furcation pathosis.