The Evaluation of Public Service Inspection: A Theoretical Framework
- 1 June 2002
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 39 (7), 1197-1212
- https://doi.org/10.1080/00420980220135563
Abstract
Inspection is an important and growing element of the regulation of public services. We develop a theoretical framework for the evaluation of inspection and illustrate the practical relevance of this framework with reference to the new Best Value inspectorate for UK local government. The framework contains three elements that facilitate the effectiveness of an inspection system (a director, a detector and an effector), five potential problems that impede its effectiveness (resistance, ritual compliance, regulatory capture, performance ambiguity and information gaps) and a pivotal mediating variable which is the expertise of inspectors. We combine these variables into a matrix that can be used as a checklist for the evaluation of inspection and we identify hypotheses concerning the circumstances that lead to successful inspection outcomes.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Regulation Inside Government: Public Interest Justifications and Regulatory FailuresPublic Administration, 2000
- Regulation of Government: Has it Increased, is it Increasing, Should it be Diminished?Public Administration, 2000
- The Regulation of Food in Britain in the 1990sPolicy & Politics, 1999
- Comparing the performance of local authorities: An evaluation of the audit commission indicatorsLocal Government Studies, 1997
- An Inspector Calls? Regulation and Accountability in Three Public ServicesPolicy & Politics, 1997
- From regulatory capture to regulated competition: An interest group analysis of the regulation of housing associations in EnglandHousing Studies, 1997
- HMI and OFSTED : Evolution or Revolution in School InspectionBritish Journal of Educational Studies, 1997
- The New Schools' Inspection SystemEducational Management & Administration, 1996
- Public Services and the Theory of RegulationPolicy & Politics, 1996
- The Dynamics of Political Control of the BureaucracyAmerican Political Science Review, 1991