Disjunctive illusory inferences and how to eliminate them
- 1 July 2009
- journal article
- Published by Springer Science and Business Media LLC in Memory & Cognition
- Vol. 37 (5), 615-623
- https://doi.org/10.3758/mc.37.5.615
Abstract
The mental model theory of reasoning postulates that individuals construct mental models of the possibilities in which the premises of an inference hold and that these models represent what is true but not what is false. An unexpected consequence of this assumption is that certain premises should yield systematically invalid inferences. This prediction is unique among current theories of reasoning, because no alternative theory, whether based on formal rules of inference or on probabilistic considerations, predicts these illusory inferences. We report three studies of novel illusory inferences that depend on embedded disjunctions-for example, premises of this sort: A or else (B or else C). The theory distinguishes between those embedded disjunctions that should yield illusions and those that should not. In Experiment 1, we corroborated this distinction. In Experiment 2, we extended the illusory inferences to a more stringently controlled set of problems. In Experiment 3, we established a novel method for reducing illusions by calling for participants to make auxiliary inferences.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- The psychological puzzle of SudokuThinking & Reasoning, 2008
- Human Reasoning and Cognitive SciencePublished by MIT Press ,2008
- Measuring the Influence of Complexity on Relational ReasoningEducational and Psychological Measurement, 2006
- The negated conditional: A litmus test for the suppositional conditional?Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2006
- Detecting cheatersTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2005
- Reasoning about relations.Psychological Review, 2005
- Goals for a Theory of Deduction: Reply to Johnson-LairdMinds and Machines, 1997
- ‘Atmosphere’, matching, and logic in syllogistic reasoningCurrent Psychology, 1995
- Deduction as verbal reasoning.Psychological Review, 1995
- Pragmatic reasoning schemasCognitive Psychology, 1985