Toward a model of grammaticality judgments
- 30 November 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Linguistics
- Vol. 46 (2), 273-330
- https://doi.org/10.1017/s0022226709990260
Abstract
This paper presents three experiments that investigate the relationship between gradient and binary judgments of grammaticality. In the first two experiments, two different groups of participants judged sentences by the method of magnitude estimation and by the method of speeded grammaticality judgments in a single session. The two experiments involved identical sentence materials but they differed in the order in which the two procedures were applied. The results show a high correlation between the magnitude estimation data and the speeded grammaticality judgments data, both within a session and across the two sessions. The third experiment was a questionnaire study in which participants judged the same sentences as either grammatical or ungrammatical without time pressure. This experiment yielded results quite similar to those of the other two experiments. Thus gradient and binary judgments both provide valuable and reliable sources for linguistic theory when assessed in an experimentally controlled way. We present a model based on Signal Detection Theory which specifies how gradient grammaticality scores are mapped to binary grammaticality judgments. Finally, we compare our experimental results to existing corpus data in order to inquire into the relationship between grammaticality and frequency of usage.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Word order in German: A corpus studyLingua, 2010
- Data and grammar: Means and individualsTheoretical Linguistics, 2007
- Data in generative grammar: The stick and the carrotTheoretical Linguistics, 2007
- The Decathlon Model of Empirical SyntaxPublished by Walter de Gruyter GmbH ,2005
- Gradience in linguistic dataLingua, 2005
- Universals and grammaticality: wh-constraints in German and EnglishLinguistics, 2005
- Gradient auxiliary selection and impersonal passivization in German: an experimental investigationJournal of Linguistics, 2003
- Gradients in Auxiliary Selection with Intransitive VerbsLanguage, 2000
- Context and distance-to-disambiguation effects in ambiguity resolution: Evidence from grammaticality judgments of garden path sentencesJournal of Memory and Language, 1987
- A theory of memory retrieval.Psychological Review, 1978