Legitimizing public schooling and innovative education policies in strict religious communities: the story of the new Haredi public education stream in Israel
- 10 January 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Journal of Education Policy
- Vol. 34 (2), 215-241
- https://doi.org/10.1080/02680939.2018.1438671
Abstract
The study explored how a group of private Haredi (ultra-Orthodox Jewish) schools legitimized an innovative non-mandatory reform. Specifically, it examined the circumstances that facilitated and hindered a coincidence of wants between the schools and the Ministry of Education, which resulted in signing agreements that changed the status of the schools from private to public. The study drew on interviews and on various documents, including contracts, summaries of meetings, and work plans. The conclusions portray the correspondence between the top-down and bottom-up processes that facilitated the reform. At their intersection, discursive interactions transpired between the Haredi inspectors at the Ministry of Education and school leaders, reflecting a mutual aspiration toward pragmatic legitimacy. The prominent barriers to the reform derived from the Ministry of Education’s strategic assumption that a quiet, unregulated reform would generate less resistance. However, this assumption led to actions that ultimately reduced the effectiveness of the discursive interactions and their ability to produce pragmatic legitimacy. We argue that to legitimize innovative non-mandatory educational reforms in strict religious groups, the State should speak in several voices: through discursive interactions led by cultural mediators, but also through official publications, regulations, and marketing campaigns that would strengthen the reform’s pragmatic legitimacy.Keywords
Funding Information
- Israeli Institute of Democracy
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Excellence or Equality in the Name of God? The Case of Ultra-Orthodox Enclave Education in IsraelThe Journal of Religion, 2012
- Faith Schools: Democracy, Human Rights and Social CohesionPolicy Futures in Education, 2012
- Speaking of change: why discourse is key to the dynamics of policy transformationCritical Policy Studies, 2011
- Post-2000 Law-based Educational Governance in Israel: From Equality to Diversity?Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 2011
- Religious Market Competition in a Richer WorldEconomica, 2009
- Education Policy as a Practice of PowerEducational Policy, 2009
- Caught in the net: the network‐entrepreneurship connection in public schoolsInternational Journal of Educational Management, 2008
- Faith schools, multiculturalism and community cohesion: Muslim and Roman Catholic state schools in England and ScotlandPolicy & Politics, 2007
- Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional ApproachesAcademy of Management Review, 1995
- The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational FieldsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983