Subannual models for catchment management: evaluating model performance on three European catchments
- 25 February 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) in Journal of Environmental Monitoring
- Vol. 11 (3), 526-539
- https://doi.org/10.1039/b823250d
Abstract
Models' abilities to predict nutrient losses at subannual timesteps is highly significant for evaluating policy measures, as it enables trends and the frequency of exceedance of water quality thresholds to be predicted. Subannual predictions also permit assessments of seasonality in nutrient concentrations, which are necessary to determine susceptibility to eutrophic conditions and the impact of management practices on water quality. Predictions of subannual concentrations are pertinent to EC Directives, whereas load estimates are relevant to the 50% target reduction in nutrient loading to the maritime area under OSPAR. This article considers the ability of four models (ranging from conceptual to fully mechanistic), to predict river flows, concentrations and loads of nitrogen and phosphorus on a subannual basis in catchments in Norway, England, and Italy. Results demonstrate that model performance deemed satisfactory on an annual basis may conceal considerable divergence in performance when scrutinised on a weekly or monthly basis. In most cases the four models performed satisfactorily, and mismatches between measurements and model predictions were primarily ascribed to the limitations in input data (soils in the Norwegian catchment; weather in the Italian catchment). However, results identified limitations in model conceptualisation associated with the damping and lagging effect of a large lake leading to contrasts in model performance upstream and downstream of this feature in the Norwegian catchment. For SWAT applied to the Norwegian catchment, although flow predictions were reasonable, the large number of parameters requiring identification, and the lack of familiarity with this environment, led to poor predictions of river nutrient concentrations.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Basin characteristics and nutrient losses: the EUROHARP catchment network perspectiveJournal of Environmental Monitoring, 2009
- Description of nine nutrient loss models: capabilities and suitability based on their characteristicsJournal of Environmental Monitoring, 2009
- Evaluating catchment-scale models for diffuse pollution policy support: some results from the EUROHARP projectEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2008
- Uncertainties in annual riverine phosphorus load estimation: Impact of load estimation methodology, sampling frequency, baseflow index and catchment population densityJournal of Hydrology, 2007
- Watershed modelling of nonpoint nitrogen losses from arable land to the Swedish coast in 1985 and 1994Ecological Engineering, 2000
- A comparison of different methods of source apportionment of nutrients to river basinsWater Science & Technology, 1999
- River flow forecasting through conceptual models part I — A discussion of principlesJournal of Hydrology, 1970