How did policy actors use mass media to influence the Scottish alcohol minimum unit pricing debate? Comparative analysis of newspapers, evidence submissions and interviews
Open Access
- 7 November 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Informa UK Limited in Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy
- Vol. 22 (2), 125-134
- https://doi.org/10.3109/09687637.2014.977228
Abstract
Aims: To explore how policy actors attempted to deliberately frame public debate around alcohol minimum unit pricing (MUP) in the UK by comparing and contrasting their constructions of the policy in public (newspapers), semi-public (evidence submissions) and private (interviews). Methods: Content analysis was conducted on articles published in ten national newspapers between 1 January 2005 and 30 June 2012. Newsprint data were contrasted with alcohol policy documents, evidence submissions to the Scottish Parliament's Health and Sport Committee and 36 confidential interviews with policy stakeholders (academics, advocates, industry representatives, politicians and civil servants). Findings: A range of policy actors exerted influence both directly (through Parliamentary institutions and political representatives) and indirectly through the mass media. Policy actors were acutely aware of mass media's importance in shaping public opinion and used it tactically to influence policy. They often framed messages in subtly different ways, depending on target audiences. In general, newspapers presented the policy debate in a "balanced'' way, but this arguably over-represented hostile perspective and suggested greater disagreement around the evidence base than is the case. Conclusions: The roles of policy actors vary between public and policy spheres, and how messages are communicated in policy debates depends on perceived strategic advantage.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Minimum Alcohol Prices and Outlet Densities in British Columbia, Canada: Estimated Impacts on Alcohol-Attributable Hospital AdmissionsAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2013
- What should be done about policy on alcohol pricing and promotions? Australian experts’ views of policy priorities: a qualitative interview studyBMC Public Health, 2013
- Industry Use of Evidence to Influence Alcohol Policy: A Case Study of Submissions to the 2008 Scottish Government ConsultationPLoS Medicine, 2013
- Escalating Coverage of Obesity in UK Newspapers: The Evolution and Framing of the “Obesity Epidemic” From 1996 to 2010Obesity, 2012
- Cleavages and co-operation in the UK alcohol industry: A qualitative studyBMC Public Health, 2012
- Alcohol industry influence on UK alcohol policy: a new research agenda for public healthCritical Public Health, 2012
- The price of a drink: levels of consumption and price paid per unit of alcohol by Edinburgh's ill drinkers with a comparison to wider alcohol sales in ScotlandAddiction, 2010
- Estimated effect of alcohol pricing policies on health and health economic outcomes in England: an epidemiological modelThe Lancet, 2010
- Newsprint media representations of the introduction of the HPV vaccination programme for cervical cancer prevention in the UK (2005–2008)Social Science & Medicine, 2010
- Media advocacy for alcohol policy support: results from the New Zealand Community Action ProjectHealth Promotion International, 1993