The Trouble with RAMSI: Reexamining the Roots of Conflict in Solomon Islands
- 1 September 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in The Contemporary Pacific
- Vol. 19 (2), 409-441
- https://doi.org/10.1353/cp.2007.0052
Abstract
While the debate that has followed the intervention by the Regional Assistance Mission to the Solomon Islands (ramsi) has centered on the suitability of the failed state label to Solomon Islands, I argue that this debate is misdirected because the concept of state failure itself is accepted uncritically. Examining what is meant by state failure is crucial, because (a) it has assumed an almost commonsensical mantle, which obscures its particular political and ideological underpinnings; and (b) it has considerable conceptual limitations that render it a problematic framework for explaining the roots and possible trajectories of the conflict in Solomon Islands. State failure is essentially a descriptive category with limited explanatory capacity, grounded in a depoliticized and ahistorical theorization of institutions, state, and society. At its core is an unhelpful preoccupation with state capacity as measured against a hypothetical legal-rational good-governance model. Conflicts are understood in this framework as the result of poor governance or recalcitrant social forces. ramsi, consequently, has sought to strengthen the institutional capacity of Solomon Islands as the key to conflict resolution as well as a preventative long-term peace-building initiative. In contrast, I argue that unless we develop a clearer understanding of the causes and dynamics of conflict, ramsi's state-building approach is likely to exacerbate rather than alleviate tensions in Solomon Islands. This approach involves a shift in emphasis away from the current fixation on institutional capacity audits associated with the failed state concept, toward a more constructive theorization of the historically contingent relationship between changing patterns of economic development and social conflict.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Have we failed our neighbour?Australian Journal of International Affairs, 2006
- Beyond state-building: Global governance and the crisis of the nation-state system in the 21st centuryThird World Quarterly, 2006
- Governance, Corruption, and Ethics in the South PacificThe Contemporary Pacific, 2005
- State functioning and state failure in the South PacificAustralian Journal of International Affairs, 2004
- ‘The sword of justice’: South Pacific trade unions and NGOs during a decade of lost developmentDevelopment in Practice, 2004
- State-Building: Governance and World Order in the 21st CenturyForeign Affairs, 2004
- Australia´s Peacekeeping Role in the Post?Cold War EraContemporary Southeast Asia, 2002
- Solomon Islands: blending traditional power and modern structures in the statePublic Administration and Development, 2002
- Establishing a Liberal Political Order Through a Constitution: The Papua New Guinea ExperienceDevelopment and Change, 1997
- The Invention of TraditionLabour / Le Travail, 1986