Edgar Dale'sPyramid of Learningin medical education: A literature review
- 11 June 2013
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis Ltd in Medical Teacher
- Vol. 35 (11), e1584-e1593
- https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159x.2013.800636
Abstract
Background: Edgar Dale's Pyramid of Learning and percentages of retained learning are cited in educational literature in a range of disciplines. The sources of the Pyramid, however, are misleading. Aims: To examine the evidence supporting the Pyramid and the extent to which it is cited in medical education literature. Methods: A review of literature (1946–2012) based on a search utilising Academic Search Complete, CINAHL, Medline and Google Scholar conducted from September to November 2012. Results: A total of 43 peer-reviewed medical education journal articles and conference papers were found. While some researchers had been misled by their sources, other authors’ interpretations of the citations did not align with the content of those citations, had no such citations, had circular references, or consulted questionable sources. There was no agreement on the percentages of learning retention, in spite of many researchers’ citing primary texts. Discussion and conclusion: The inappropriate citing of the Pyramid and its associated percentages in medical education literature is widespread and continuous. This citing undermines much of the published work, and impacts on research-based medical education literature. While the area of learning/teaching strategies and amount of retention from each is an area for future research, any reference to the Pyramid should be avoided.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Podcasting as a goal oriented toy in educationAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2012
- Medical students as teachers in clinical skills trainingEducation in Medicine Journal, 2011
- Correlation of the summary method with learning stylesAdvances in Physiology Education, 2011
- Practitioner commentary on: Fridén, K. The librarian as a teacher: experiences from a problem‐based setting. Health Libraries Review 1996, 13, 3–7Health Information and Libraries Journal, 2008
- Deconstructing the construction of a learning module on practice developmentEuropean Journal of Cancer Care, 2007
- Adding problem-based learning tutorials to a traditional lecture-based curriculum: a pilot study in a dental schoolOdontology, 2005
- The ABCs of Case TeachingInternational Studies Perspectives, 2000
- Best evidence medical education (BEME): a plan for actionMedical Teacher, 2000
- Improving exercise adherenceTopics in Geriatric Rehabilitation, 1991
- AN EXPERIMENT INVOLVING SUBSTITUTION OF TAPE/SLIDE PROGRAMMES FOR LECTURESThe Lancet, 1969