Exploring women's academic careers in cross‐national perspective
- 9 January 2009
- journal article
- Published by Emerald in Equal Opportunities International
- Vol. 28 (1), 9-23
- https://doi.org/10.1108/02610150910933604
Abstract
Purpose – In recent years, several countries and/or higher education institutions have adopted equal opportunity policies to promote women's access to the upper levels of the academic career structure. The purpose of this paper is to argue that there is no universal solution to the glass ceiling that women face within academia. Insofar as the feminisation process evolves according to a variety of models, according to national and occupational context, the solutions adopted in one context may prove to be ineffective elsewhere. Design/methodology/approach – Analysis of the different models of occupational feminisation is based on a secondary analysis of the sociological literature on the subject, combined with recent data on women's access to academic positions in France and Germany. Findings – Although there are similarities in the structure of the academic labour market across countries and in the rate of feminisation of the most prestigious academic positions, the precise mechanisms through which women gain access to an academic career vary significantly from one national context to another. This cross-national variation would tend to suggest that there will also be variation when it comes to defining the most effective policy measures for increasing women's access to the upper echelons of the academic hierarchy. Indeed, different models of gender equality in academia may lead to very different results with regard to existing gender relations. Originality/value – The paper uses the available sociological literature on the feminisation process to examine how different measures adopted to promote women's access to the highest echelons of the academic career structure may have different effects on the reproduction and/or transformation of the dominant sex/gender system.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Women's Scientific Employment and Family Formation: A Longitudinal PerspectiveGender, Work & Organization, 2008
- Editorial: Breaking Boundaries: Women in AcademiaGender, Work & Organization, 2008
- Les processus de féminisation au travail : entre différenciation, assimilation et « dépassement du genre »Sociologies pratiques, 2007
- Foreword: Why be Interested in Women's Position in Academe?Gender, Work & Organization, 2003
- Women succeeding in the sciences: theories and practices across disciplines, edited by Jody Bart. Pp. 287. £19.95. 1999. ISBN 1 55753 122 6 (Purdue University Press, distributed by Eurospan ). - Proofs from THE BOOK (2nd edn), by Martin Aigner and Gunter M. Ziegler. Pp. 223. £18.50. 2001. ISBN 3 540 67865 4 (Springer-Verlag). - Mathematics of the nineteenth century 1: mathematical logic – algebra – number theory – probability (2nd edn), edited by A. N. Kolmogorov and A. P. Yushkevich, revised by Abe Shenitzer. Pp. 328. SFrl28 (hb) SFr58 (pb). 2001. ISBN 3 7643 6441 6 (hb) 3 7643 6442 4 (pb) (Birkhäuser). - Fermat’s Last Theorem: new simple proof, by Shafi U. Ahmed. Pp. 42. £10.00. 2001. ISBN 0 948331 10 0 (Oaktown Publications). - Serge Lang Collected Papers, by Serge Lang. Volume III: 1978–1990. Pp. 393. £55.00. 2000. ISBN 0 387 98800 9. Volume IV: 1990–1996. Pp. 471. £55.00. 2000. ISBN 0 387 98804 1. Volume V: with Jay Jorgenson 1993–1999. Pp. 393. £61.50. 2001. ISBN 0 387 95030 3 (Springer-Verlag). - Complex analysis in one variable (2nd edn), by Raghavan Narasimhan and Yves Nievergelt. Pp. 400. SFrll8. 2001. ISBN 0 8176 4164 5 (Birkhäuser). - Topics in non-linear functional analysis, by Louis Nirenberg, notes by Ralph A. Artino. Pp. 145. £14.50. 2001. ISBN 0 8218 2819 3 (AMS/Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, distributed by Oxford University Press). - Optimal solutions of nonlinear equations, by Krzysztof A. Sikorski. Pp. 248. £39.50. 2001. ISBN 0 19 510690 3 (Oxford University Press). - Introduction to combinatorical torsions, by Vladimir Turaev. Pp. 136. SFr32. 2001. ISBN 3 7643 6403 3 (Birkhäuser). - The geometry of the group of symplectic diffeomorphisms, by Leonid Polterovich. Pp. 152. SFr34. 2001. ISBN 3 7643 6432 7 (Birkhäuser). - Dimensionality reducing expansion of multivariate integration, by Tian-Xiao He. Pp. 240. SFrll8. 2001. ISBN 0 8176 4170 X (Birkhäuser).The Mathematical Gazette, 2002
- La feminisation d'une profession est-elle le signe d'une baisse de prestige ?Travail, genre et sociétés, 2001
- Gender Relations and Employment: The Impact of OccupationWork, Employment & Society, 1998
- Gendered Cultures and Performance Appraisal: The Experience of Women AcademicsGender, Work & Organization, 1996
- Why ‘Work’? Gender and the ‘Total Social Organization of Labour’Gender, Work & Organization, 1995
- Exploring a Research Agenda of the Feminization of the Legal Profession: Theories of Gender and Social ChangeLaw & Social Inquiry, 1989