Investigating the Claims of Konstantin Buteyko, M.D., Ph.D.: The Relationship of Breath Holding Time to End Tidal CO2and Other Proposed Measures of Dysfunctional Breathing
- 1 March 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Mary Ann Liebert Inc in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine
- Vol. 14 (2), 115-123
- https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2007.7204
Abstract
Konstantin Buteyko, M.D., Ph.D., claimed that breath holding time (BHT) can be used to detect chronic hyperventilation and that BHT predicts alveolar CO(2) (Pa(CO(2))) according to his patented mathematical formula. The Buteyko Breathing Technique (BBT) is believed to correct chronic hyperventilation as evidenced by increased BHT. In this study, we test Buteyko's claims and explore the relationship between BHT and end-tidal carbon dioxide (ETCO(2)) as well as measures of dysfunctional breathing (DB) including the Nijmegen questionnaire, the Self Evaluation of Breathing Questionnaire, and thoracic dominant breathing pattern. Eighty-three (83) adults healthy or suspected of having dysfunctional breathing, 29 with abnormal spirometry readings, 54 with normal spirometry. BHT, performed according to BBT protocols, was measured along with ETCO(2) and other measures of DB including the Nijmegen questionnaire, and manual assessment of respiratory motion, a palpatory technique for measuring thoraco-abdominal balance during breathing. Correlations between measures of DB were made in the whole sample and also in subgroups with normal or abnormal spirometry. DB measures were compared in normal and abnormal spirometry groups. The results revealed a negative correlation between BHT and ETCO(2) (r= -0.241, p<0.05), directly opposite to Buteyko's claims. BHT was significantly shorter in people with abnormal spirometry (FEV(1) or FVC<15% below predicted), with no difference in ETCO(2) levels between the abnormal and normal spirometry groups. In the abnormal spirometry group, lower BHT was found to correlate with a thoracic dominant breathing pattern. (r= -0.408, p<0.028). Although BHT does not predict resting ETCO(2), it does correlate with breathing pattern in subjects with abnormal spirometry. It is proposed that altered breathing pattern could contribute to breathing symptoms such as dyspnea and that breathing therapies such as BBT might influence symptoms by improving the efficiency of the biomechanics of breathing.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Breathing therapies and bronchodilator use in asthmaThorax, 2006
- Hyperinflation, Dyspnea, and Exercise Intolerance in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary DiseaseProceedings of the American Thoracic Society, 2006
- Prevalence of dysfunctional breathing in patients treated for asthma in primary care: cross sectional surveyBMJ, 2001
- Psychological and physiological predictors of response to carbon dioxide challenge in individuals with panic disorder.Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 2000
- The hyperventilation syndrome: a syndrome under threat?Thorax, 1997
- Hyperventilation syndrome: an elegant but scientifically untenable conceptStroke Prevention in Atrial Fibrillation, 1997
- Unsteadiness of breathing in patients with hyperventilation syndrome and anxiety disordersEuropean Respiratory Journal, 1997
- Respiratory Muscles and DyspneaSeminars in Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 1992
- Thoracoabdominal mechanics during tidal breathing in normal subjects and in emphysema and fibrosing alveolitis.Thorax, 1983
- Evaluation of breath holding in hypercapnia as a simple clinical test of respiratory chemosensitivity.Thorax, 1975